Current date/time is Fri Apr 26, 2024 8:02 am

Search found 15 matches for Steveland W.

Game 28: Guess Who?

I'd like to apoligize for not having said anything for a bit I'm currently a bit sick so I've been getting rest anyways I said I would do an updated readlist, there is something I want to get out of the way first, I'm gonna sort of seperate them into different posts, I want to make reads on 2 important people in this post (I want to make this post first since I find these 2 reads to be the most important)  which is why i said i would sort of seperate them, I'm going to update my current reads on Molly and Nathaniel as I believe it's very possible one of them will be lynched today from seeing whats happened so far, I'm going to start off with Molly and than I will do one for Nathaniel, I intend to look through all of their posts and try to see their perspectives like Mollys reasoning to lynch Nathaniel which i talked a bit about yesterday but I think it's worth going over again, I'm also going to focus a bit more on the posts that they made yesterday and today so far as they are more relevant so they'll hold more relevance to the current discussion

So lets stop keeping things waiting and get on with the readlist, as I said before I am going to start with Molly

Molly: So first off I'm gonna readdress the reasons she has stated for lynching him (Before I give her a read) in an attempt to look them over to consider things and see if its possible to show that these reasons are / arent correct one of the reasons why she is sring Nathaniel is his activity in a certain time period and looking back at it he was gone for 3/11 and 3/12 (Which he said he would be) then the DL happened until the 15th and he was posting on the 15th so I dont think theres a problem with that unless im mistaken somehow? Now another reason she says is that he's being defensive which is a true point but wouldnt it be more because of you sring him everyday, and going after him each day, but yes he is being defensive but i dont find this enough to be condemming for a lynch, now the final reason you had said is that his reads lack content, I mean he just gave a complete readlist with everything and I'd consider that content, but to be more relevant with your posts he did analyze peoples reads to look through them and give his own opinion on them, which I find as a bit of content

Anyways onto the overall Molly read so far, so the original read that I had given you was that I was a little but towards suspicious but mostly neutral overall, so I'm gonna be looking at the posts that youve given thus far from my initial readlist, so the first post that you had made since my initial readlist was that you were changing your read on me to more townlike (Gutread)so I dont think theres anything too suspicious about it, the next thing you posted was a response to my analysis of your reasons for lynching Nathaniel, so out of the 5 of these reasons that you had given right there at that point 5 of them were easily debateble to being useless or not, one of them you yourself had said that it was alright so why even include that? Another one was your noting of his activity but as I had previously stated there is no problem with his activity at that point so thats 3 explained so far, next he asked for you to clarify on something so that he could look at it but you say that it was a useless post although you had answered his question at the top of that page, finally his reads I'm pretty sure he gave a genuine readlist, and he never said that he agreed with you in any part of his reads. So from this I kinda see you as tunneling Nathaniel so it's a bit scummy IMO. So the next one you made was in response to Nathaniel about, so one of the things i found of interest is that you saw Nathaniels posts as more agreeing with people and him having neutral reads so I'm gonna address some of this, I also had a bunch of overall neutral reads and was really only pointing stuff out yet you dont say anything about that about my original readlist, He was also giving his own comment on other peoples readlists and such so i'd find it logical for him to be agreeing with some reads if they are similar to his, In that post you didnt really widen your perspective to me in consideration to my original readlist which I thought was me kinda just pointing stuff out and giving a bunch of people neutral reads. So next post was the first one for today, which ill ignore as it was just you lynching Nathaniel, the next post that you had made is defending yourself against Aya, and trying to give yourself a reason for lynching Nathaniel which I think is still incorrect, defending is alright, (In this so far I do mention Nathaniel a lot since a good variety of her posts mention Nathaniel) Honestly i feel as though youve been tunneling Nathaniel and I still can't agree with your reasons for lynching him, and I cannot see good reasoning to either, even from looking from your perspective I still think its a bit shaky to only lynch him (You did lynch Wilma on Day 2 I know that) So im leaning towards scum for you since as I said before I think that it's apparent to me that youre tunneling Nathaniel, and even if you said you werent tunneling you dont have much reasoning to do so so for Molly I think she's scummy in this case

Next my read for Nathaniel I'm mostly going to be focusing once again on the posts made more recently so honestly i've been reading through a bit, and you do quote things a lot er well pretty often but you refer back to posts of others and bring up information people have given before hand, and you also analyze peoples reads which I think is good, you also ask clarifying questions which I find helpful since you make people clarify what they mean or what they say so then they'd give better information, you did mention you have some proof of Molly + Grimm could u please show it, honestly people have said youve been defensive which you have been but it's justifiable since youve been lynched every day, and I could see myself doing that tbh, honestly this is probably mostly a repeat of what I said in my original readlist I still TR you, in my eyes you had a good reason to plurshift to mirror serena being that a lot of what she did say was scummy

Honestly I find it possible that Molly or Nathaniel is scum (Im obvs leaning more towards Molly) but i think 1 is scum 1 is town is a most likely scenario but town v town is also possible
by Steveland W.
on Fri Mar 24, 2017 8:15 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Aya Y. wrote:
Steveland W. wrote:2) I know everyone has noticed this at this point but what would everyones opinions be on giving Aya some pressure? (This is due to her little contribtion this does not mean to start a lynch on her merely put pressure on her so she would start doing stuff (Like give her readlist)


You act as if I'm not able to see this or am not here.  I'll make and post my readlist tonight.


I feel like you took this really badly from my perspective and u sound super annoyed (Which u prolly are)

If its about the contribution part its b/c you said like 1 thing (Yesterday (Im not counting the other days)) (I may have missed another) with you disagreeing with Nathaniel being lynched and reasoning to lynch Serena instead which is contribution i'd just like to see more tbh,

But it's also b/c i never see u posting or saying anything (which is why I feel that you are never here), the reason I wanted pressure on u is so that you'd talk a bit more (Which I dont think is unreasonable to ask for), and I do know that you'd see it since you strike me as a person that reads through everything
by Steveland W.
on Tue Mar 21, 2017 8:51 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Alright so theres a couple things I'd like to address
1) I intend to update my reads and look over (a couple times) what was said yesterday, and compare it with what I initially had my reads as, and try and give people a better read / updated read (It will take a bit for me to give an accurate read on Mrs. Grimm seeing as a sub just joined the game so I want to use this day as an opportunity to A: Get a read on Mrs. Grimm finally and B: Hopefully get a correct lynch) (I will most likely have a readlist by tomorrow but no promises as I have a lot of work to get done)

2) I know everyone has noticed this at this point but what would everyones opinions be on giving Aya some pressure? (This is due to her little contribtion this does not mean to start a lynch on her merely put pressure on her so she would start doing stuff (Like give her readlist)

3) Some comments of my own on Mrs. Grimms readlist, I feel as though (although he's dead) Guy F also brought up pretty solid points (perhaps better than mine) so even if hes dead I feel as though he was a good TR rather than a SR, and also I'd like to point out that he wasnt trying to lynch u Mrs. Grimm, he wanted your sub to talk since he noticed your sub was online yet never spoke the post that I am referring to can be found on page 7 if you'd like to look at it (I also have it here (Hopefully I did that right))

Guy F. wrote:
Aya Y. wrote:
Wilma F. wrote:s
Also for whatever reason Guy F. is randomly putting letters in bold? I'm just confused with this guy


Lulu L. wrote:Also this is more off-topic but what is up with everyone saying I am town lol

like we have Nathaniel and Steveland "I'm confirmed to myself" then Wilma came in with "I'm personally convinced that I am town" like

Question


Pretty sure Guy F. is spelling out I AM TOWN in bold in his posts.


Aya Y. wrote:
Nathaniel E. wrote:
Aya Y. wrote:

Pretty sure Guy F. is spelling out I AM TOWN in bold in his posts.


btw exactly in what post is he spelling that out (for some reason i can't see bold too clearly on my computer)


He just bolds a single letter in each post.  Reading them in order so far spells out I AM TO.


These were the only posts she did on day 2, i am p sure molly was referring to the fact throughout the whole of day 2 she just wrote these things which are not good points at all. Obviously not every post has to be "perfect" but to not post anything useful throughout the whole of day 2? Therefore i'm p sure molly's point still stands and your argument is null and void.

What annoys me more however is that mrs grimm and lulu were online yesterday! Mrs grimm especially, who I know must have a lot to say due to disappearing at the start of day 2 (?). Lulu, as I said before, is only active when someone is accusing her of mafia. Yes she defends herself well but it only means that she's a good player with a good sense of logic (i am literally repeating one of my older posts so see that one). I want to make them both talk but i can only lynch one of them so...

Lynch Mrs Grimm


Finally I'd like to ask a question, I'm going to look through Guy F's reads in particular when I go through the posts is it worth looking at who he posed a threat to (If he SR anyone, and was making a case against them) and consider that to be someone that killed him?
by Steveland W.
on Tue Mar 21, 2017 6:08 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

So I'm gonna do some commentary of my own on Lulu's post as well so I do wanna say this upfront tbh I like how you organized it and everything with their Tone, Motive and interactions that actually looks pretty good but anyways onto the comments that I have

So Im gonna go in the order that you did in listing them

So like you said we dont have much information about Mrs. Grimm (even though she hasnt talked much q-q) we definitely dont have enough to justify a lynch yet but I'd definitely think that we should give her some pressure tomorrow in order to get her to start talking since we dont have any info about her

So next you listed Aya, She hasnt given much today I think she said like 1 thing so far I'd like to get her readlist for what she thinks of people at this point I think that'd be something we should be asking from her today at least, for me she overall doesnt seem scummy but she doesnt really seem town like you said

Next you had Guy F on your list, I've been seeing his posts all throughout the day so far, and I'd have to agree on what youve said I'm leaning more towards town on him at this time now

Honestly i dont think i need to comment on what you said about Serena since youre also seeing what a few others are seeing about her, the thing I  dont see from her though is any "formal" readlist i'd like to see what she thinks about the current players given that shes going to most likely be lynched, and it'd be useful to have one from her the only form of "reads" i saw was her talking about was molly really, and her commenting on my readlist (I may or may not have missed something of hers but if i did do let me know)

Oh if its not too much to ask could u use that style of making your reads again (The way u did it with the first 2)? I actually quite like how its done and it'd seem more useful than not
by Steveland W.
on Sat Mar 18, 2017 8:57 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Ok so first I'm just gonna state who im going to be responding to / commenting upon in this Post first I will be talking to LuLu about the point that they just made recently, next I intend to respond to Molly, and Wilma.

So First as I said I'd like to talk with Lulu first, So I do like the point that you made in your post, and I'd believe that it would be a possible theory on peoples activity to decrease knowing the circumstances But there are some things that I'd like to bring up in "contrary" to what you said, the things that I was thinking that since mafia Does get a kill tonight It'd also be logical for people to increase their activity since with more people analyzing posts and etc It'd increase the chances of us getting the correct lynch for today (Which I believe its important for us to), since there'd be more content to look at, I also want to propose another theory perhaps mafia would want to be TR now more than ever since they will start being able to kill a player every night from now on, and who they are could become apparent due to those that die

So next I wish to respond to Molly on what they had said (Overdue yes, but here nonetheless) (Also to clarify this is about her post on Page 6 btw about her response to my post of her reasoning's to lynch Nat) (I do feel as 1 or 2 of these points deserve to be mentioned a bit)

So for the 4th one (Notes I said  something and that he will look at it later) <-- that one
So for that you did leave out the part where he asked about which post of Lulu's it was(Im assuming this is the part youre talking about), from what I see of this I think he was just asking for you to clarify of which post of hers it was that you were making reference(s) to, so I could see it plausible as him being confused about which post you were talking about in that (If this isnt the right post lemme know please in case i'm making an error)

I think thats the only one I really wanted to talk about since I feel as though the others have a bit of truth to them (No I am not changing my perspective on Nat at this time)

Finally as I said at the beginning I wanted to respond to Wilma

Well 1st (I am able to find more time, and as i did state before its my first forum game so i was still "getting into it" so to speak) next I think that its extremely important to talk today since tonight is the first night that mafia will be recieving a kill, so today's lynch is quite important (I'm saying its a bit more important than the other days since those days in my eyes were to get the game started) tbh b/c If we get 1 scum today then it could greatly alter who the scum choose to kill. Also another point that I'd like to make is that I've been talking everyday but I see what youre saying about me not doing much since I didnt talk much the other days. But i'd like to make a request end things out, when you have the time to make a full (more current) readlist could u do so please, I'd like to see the thoughts of what you think about everyone at this point in time (As in who you currently lean towards town for, currently sr and such
by Steveland W.
on Sat Mar 18, 2017 3:22 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Ok so next is Nathaniels that I'd like to talk about and maybe add a bit to my reads as I feel one is poorly explained (ish) (I'm not gonna do much talking in this one I'll just bring up the ones I feel absolutely necessary)

So first for Lulu yes I will agree on the point you made about her that it is entirely possible for her to just be a townie defending herself

Next off for Mrs. Grimm I didn't give her a read yet since theres nothing really to read of hers but I do feel as though I could give her a read based on the lack of what she's given at this point in time so I will begin to reconsider what I think of her

Other than that I don't feel the necessity to comment on the rest of his post but I do thank you for bringing up all of Serenas posts and looking at them yourself

by Steveland W.
on Fri Mar 17, 2017 3:33 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Alright so to start this off (Nathaniel I will comment on your thoughts next) (Molly I will most likely look through what you just said (Yes I looked at it)  but I do want to respond to Serena first as she is the person i'm currently on)

Ok so Serena now there is another question I'd like to ask you that I'd like you to consider for me, Why was it that you had nothing to contribute on / about anyone else? I feel like it's a simple question to ask yet I  feel like you only thought about Muramasa for that day and no one else from what I'm looking at unless for some reason I'm missing something
Also there's another question I do have for you, If you did SR Muramasa wouldn't you have lynched him? You did nothing of the sort, the only thing you did was unlynch me and go straight to saying nothing for the rest of that day (Perhaps this is a stupid question but yet I'd feel like it would make sense to lynch someone you sr)
by Steveland W.
on Fri Mar 17, 2017 3:08 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

So in this post I'd like to assess Molly's lynch reasons on Nathaniel but there is something I wish to address within my post first so the first  thing I did notice within one of your more recent posts is that that you believe I ignored the fact that you were on Wilma for a majority of the day yesterday (This is something that I did miss) So I was looking through some posts (I may or may not have missed one I was looking for sorta specific ones dont kill me on missing 1) The ones I was paying more attention to were the ones involving you stating reasons to lynch Nathaniel / lynching him so during day 1 the reasoning there was for generally useless posts / filler (Atm I believe this reason is out the window since I think its obvious to say that his posts aren't really useless) Next there was also the BW so the thing I did see is that he did give his reasoning for lynching Muramasa (Reasoning was for not defending himself and since he wasnt contributing so its kinda justafiable for him to lynch him rather than it being a BW) The next thing you had said about him was that he didnt give his opinion on the current lynch situation, but yet when he had lynched Muramasa he kinda did give his opinion there with saying how they should be lynched if they arent going to contribute or defend themself. Next another thing for a reason you said was that he suddenly stopped posting (He did say he wouldnt be here for a bit, and yes he also did correct you and you also did acknowledge that you didnt see that post but that is one of the reasonings that you pointed out so I do want to include that) Finally you say that Wilma and him are passively fine with whatever the other person does, honestly I feel as if this reason isnt a super condemming reason to lynch Nathaniel as this is the only reason that I can find that cant really be refuted at this point. Honestly he's not that good of a lynch and like Aya had said he gives helpful information, and in my own opinion I quite like the way he assesses people's reads, and other information people bring up (I did like his contribution on the reads that I had given) Mainly the purpose of this post if for me to bring to light the reasons you've ever given for Nathaniel to be lynched, and theres really only 1 reason that cant be refuted at this point, so I dont find a Nathaniel Lynch to be very good for the town at this point in time considering how there's only 1 reason that I've been able to find where as there's people that have more reasoning to be lynched if there was a reasoning that you gave that I missed please let me know I'd be more than happy to assess it within a post

I do intend to hopefully be able to look through some more things tomorrow and bring more information to the table I do wish to respond to Nathaniels comments about my reads which I will do in another post most likely tomorrow (Tomorrow for me)
by Steveland W.
on Thu Mar 16, 2017 9:49 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Alright I have read through a bit and have seen people (Or just Nathaniel maybe) requesting peoples reads, and its also at a certain point in the game where I believe it is most appropriate to start giving reads since there is a lot of information at our disposal at this point

(But before I start that there is something that I wish to address) Yes i do realize i dont have many posts (This is my first forum game and I still have a lot to learn) However that is no excuse or reasoning for me to not try and post informatively as much as i can (I do realize that it is a terrible mistake of mine and i will try to correct it for the future (Although I shouldnt have made it in the first place))

So To the reads portion of this post I'll try and give reads for as many people as I can within the game but there might be some on which I dont have a particular read to

So I'll start off with my reads at this point

Mirror Serena, I am somewhat suspicious of her for a few reasons, now the first has been said many times before so it's perhaps not worth mentioning but to clarify it is about her Day 1 Post which said she had nothing to contribute to our discussion, In another post I did ask her to explain why she had nothing to contribute to the discussion and this is part of my next reasoning for why I am slightly suspicious of her, When she did come back to the thread and finally answered some people I felt as though she completely ignored the question that I had asked and tried to avoid it completely as she never tried to address it herself instead she gave the general inactivity speech that others have also given already the next part of my suspicions about her is that even though she said that she's back there's still not much content of worth (In my eyes at least) within her posts, yesterday while Brianna was being lynched I also felt that She just jumped on without any reasoning of her own the only 'reason' she really gave was because she agreed with what Guy F had said, and without any reasoning of her own for lynching them, I also feel as though she was a too wanting to get Plurarity off of herself when she was being lynched, and the deadline approaching. Also I feel as though her attempt or promise to contribute more hasnt been met since most of her posts dont have much in them when you compare them to for example Wilma, who also said that they would try and contribute more (I'll say more on Wilma a bit more down)


I'll discuss Mrs. Grimm next, As of right now I dont truly believe that I would be able to give her a proper read due there not being much content to pull from atm but from what I can pull from (Or the lack of what I can pull from) Will lead me to give her a somewhat Neutral read on her (At this point I do want to agree with those above in saying that she definitely needs to contribute today but I also feel that a lynch shouldnt be based solely upon her lack of contribution seeing as it's very easily likely for her to not be scum, however it is a possibility that she is scum, and there would possibly be better lynches at the time)


Next off I'd like to give my current read on Nathaniel as I do feel that its more than appropriate (or overdue) for this one b/c of the variety of posts he has had so ill give this next read, As of right now im getting a townie sort of vibe off of Nathaniel seeing as he has had what I believe a decent variety of contribution, as he constantly gives reads, and constantly updates them about every day if not more often, and he is also always looking for an opportunity to contribute by reading his earlier posts i'm somewhat certain of this atm i feel as though he is a townie that wants to be able to lynch a scum today, also another point that I do want to add is that whenever someone mentions him in a post, or asks him a question or something of the sort he actually answers their questions and also gives his thoughts where they are due and he defends himself when necessary without giving the vibe of feeling desperate to defend oneself

Next I'll say what I think on Aya at this point on time as of this point, (Similarily to me she hasnt made many posts (7) but im not going to criticize her on that) I dont know if I have more of a suspicious feeling of her or more of a neutral feeling towards her, since as of right now I dont see much content to pull from in what she has posted thus far but i do feel as though about 1/2 (maybe a little more) have been more fillery than informational, however I still cant see much content to pull from to give her the more neutral read, apart from me I do believe that she is a person that It would be good to see more of and some more contribution from so for now I'm slighly suspicious of her due to the lack of content, and contribution thus far (I perhaps might sound like a hypocrite as i havent posted much but I do try to at least include content within the posts)


Next off I'll give my current thoughts on Wilma, As of right now I do want to give her more of the townie feelings seeing as she did say that she would contribute more after what I feel to be a sincere explanation of her absence and then she immediately did fulfill on what she had owed in terms of content and what not with some reads of her own at that point in the game, again she also is another person that addresses people whenever they mention her / respond to her similarily with Nathaniel, and she doesn't ignore them at this point I feel as though she is another townie like Nathaniel that wants to be able to find scum

Next off I'm going to address my thoughts / comments on Molly at this point there's obviously a lot of content of yours to look at, right now I feel that the only person you want to be lynched is Nathaniel, which is alright I guess(A bit tunnelish to me)? But I also feel that shifting your attention to those that lack content within their posts is something that you should do since I believe at least there are those that we should worry about more than just him. Next you did state within your post(s) that you're lynching him for reasons said above yet some of these reasons aren't super credible (maybe that's the word?) since in one post you did mention that he was mostly filler but I feel that at this point that's null and void since there is a lot of contribution from him, Next off I do have a question for you (ATM I feel as though you didn't explain this much / didnt really touch upon it, but why did you believe that a Wilma + Nathaniel was most likely at that point, next off whenever you could give an indepth analysis into people that would also be greatly appreciated (You have given some indepth analysis but more would be good too) Atm a bit neutral on you from what I stated above i'm not immediately saying suspicious but i'm not leaning towards town either so i'm about in the middle maybe a bit more towards suspicious

Next I'd like to address Lulu,  honestly I don't what to think of you yet but I do want to be able to address everyone within this post so I'll ask you a few questions what are your current thoughts on our situation currently? Next I feel as though most of your "longer" posts have been more centered towards defending yourself even though it is reasonable to defend yourself, I feel as though you havent contributed in terms of trying to find scum / giving current reads, and I'd like to ask why is that? For now thats really all I have about you and ill continue on to the last person I want to address

So lastly Guy F (I've addressed everyone else I think? If I missed someone i'd like to be told so i would be able to address that person with my current thoughts) Right now youre also another person that I dont have a side on which I am leaning more towards than the other if anything maybe more towards town tbh since youre another person that has given their reads, and contributes to a point in which you address those that also address you within their posts, I also feel as though the lynch you started on Brianna was justifiable from what she said which you had already discussed within your own post but perhaps I'll ask u a question to end this what are your current thoughts on a Serena Lynch, and thoughts on those you havent had the oppurtunity to address within your posts as of now


As of right now I am going to be placing a lynch on Serena as she is the person that most of my suspicions are on, and I'd like to see some sort of explantion from her as to why she ignored the question that I had asked her so for reasons stated above Lynch Mirror Serena

by Steveland W.
on Wed Mar 15, 2017 9:05 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Alright so first off thank you Wilma for responding so soon, I did read through what you had to say so I guess I'll respond to some of the things you posted, while looking through all the posts (a few times) I did notice that Mrs. Grimm has had little content to pull from in her posts (So yes im agreeing with you on this for now) since most of her posts if not all were during day 1, and were pretty short and I havent seen much of her during this day (If at all) so atm right now I want to give her an oppurtunity to give her posts some content with some form of reads or contribution it would be nice to see something

Next off I'm gonna address Mirror Serena from what I've seen so far the first thing that she did do was lynch me on day 1 (RVS of course) and the next thing she did that day was unlynch and not say anything and her posts didnt have much to contribute to the discussion, and she hasnt said anything at all yet today, This is another person I want to give some sort of an oppurtunity to to give some input before I say more on her.

Next for this post, Honestly between Wilma and Natheniel I don't think that it is plausible that they are a scum team, both of them have given some sort of input to the current discussion at hand (Which is quite helpful), and are actually actively attempting to find the scum within the game

Honestly to sum things up i guess I'd like to see more content from Mrs. Grimm and some kind of contribution from Mirror Serena (again yes agreeing with those above on this) and perhaps an explanation on why Mirror Serena had nothing to say yesterday, like read through what people have said and give what you think

As of right now I dont believe I have enough of a Scum Read on someone to place a lynch on anyone based on what i've seen so far I'd want to give them an oppurtunity to speak their minds

(Also AJ I will not be here on the 11th just a heads up)
by Steveland W.
on Fri Mar 10, 2017 3:21 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Wilma, When I was noting activity of the game I wasn't excluding myself (In that I acknowledged that I wasn't as active as the others too)

Next off It looks like to me that you don't have anything positive to say about anyone in the game so far except for Aya (Maybe) , and how are you unable to get a read or anything on Nathaniel he's been basically the most active and has enough posts to look through to get some kind of read on him. Could you say how you cant get reads on him?

Next off you never really stated in your posts why you distrust Mrs. Grimm could you include some reasoning or some fragments of her posts that make you distrust her? From what I've read from her posts I don't see much reason to distrust her, as she gave reasoning for her lynches one of them at the start of the game the next of Muramasa for not contributing and nothing that was really giving reasoning to not trust her.

Lastly Why a lynch for Lulu, it looks like to me there is better reasoning to lynch others than Lulu, like Serena for example who you said hasn't done much if anything and doesn't seem to care, wouldn't that be better reasoning to lynch someone to try and get them to do something.
by Steveland W.
on Thu Mar 09, 2017 4:15 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

Oh oops I forgot that scum don't have kills n1 and n2 disregard the part of analyzing who the scum killed / the reason they were killed
by Steveland W.
on Mon Mar 06, 2017 5:02 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

honestly from what I'm seeing (As we all are there is a lot of inactivity I'm not trying to exclude myself from this) our best thing (IMO) is the lynch currently since Muramasa isnt even trying to defend themself and give reasons to why they shouldn't be lynched, and then we could analyze who the scum kills to try and get something off of that as to why they killed them / perhaps who would have some kind of reasoning to kill that person (If we could find any) and perhaps go from there?
by Steveland W.
on Mon Mar 06, 2017 4:59 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

I haven't talked much (Even though its my first day in game since I just joined) I'm just trying to assess what's been said so far

ATM: what I'm thinking is agreeing with those above talking about Muramasa; contributing is more important than filler next, we also need peeps to talk a bit more so reads could become a thing (Possibly Muramasa to talk more) and Mrs. Grimm how come u unlynched in Rvs?

by Steveland W.
on Sat Mar 04, 2017 7:57 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Game 28: Guess Who?

I am here :O

I'm also confirmed town.. confirmed to myself at least
by Steveland W.
on Sat Mar 04, 2017 6:47 pm
 
Search in: Mafia Games
Topic: Game 28: Guess Who?
Replies: 288
Views: 10601

Back to top

Jump to: