Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

It's night x.x

Silver B., the Town Doctor, was frozen to death.

Raiden Y., the Vanilla Townie, was burned to death.

Day 3 Commence!

Votecount 3.0
*************************************
Foster U.(0)-
Jimmy Q.(0)-
Hanzou S.(0)-
Lily G.(0)-
Shigeo H.(0)-
Chigusa X.(0)-
Saiga Z.(0)-
Toran D.(0)-
Volt K.(0)-
Not Voting(9)- Shigeo H., Toran D., Volt K., Hanzou S., Lily G., Chigusa X., Foster U., Saiga Z., Jimmy Q.
*************************************
There are 9 players alive so it takes 5 to hammer.
Deadline is Sunday the 17th at 9pm EST.

As I said yesterday, I consider Jimmy to be the most scummy and I stick by that belief.

lynch Jimmy Q.

hi, lets try to think this out

3 mafia left, 9 alive. Its a 1/3 chance to hit a mafia. I find it weird that the mafia would kill Raiden and Silver B, instead of Saiga, Chigusa, and Hanzou.

if foster and or lilly is mafia, he could have avoided killing Saiga because that would clearly put the blame on him.

idk im just confused on why the mafia is killing people that are considered scummy and not the people leading the village

Jimmy Q. wrote:hi, lets try to think this out

3 mafia left, 9 alive. Its a 1/3 chance to hit a mafia. I find it weird that the mafia would kill Raiden and Silver B, instead of Saiga, Chigusa, and Hanzou.

if foster and or lilly is mafia, he could have avoided killing Saiga because that would clearly put the blame on him.  

idk im just confused on why the mafia is killing people that are considered scummy and not the people leading the village

Because they know how we're going to think are trying to psych us out maybe?

It all makes sense now.....eileen died because Silver B thought eileen was scum, so he didnt protect her.

I find the kills pretty weird actually. But I dont know if it was by accident or they somehow knew.....

Honestly I just want EVERYBODY to post their reads and their thoughts because info is scarse right now

Well at the moment I would say Lily is the scummiest. She is quick to lynch and lurking. I want everyone's thoughts especially Foster, Toran, Shigeo and Jimmy.

This has caught my attention....

Chigusa X. Last Visit Today at 3:33 pm
Volt K. Last Visit Today at 3:08 pm

Day started at Today at 2:37 pm so why didnt they post anything? I find that very weird....

Oh and Hanzou too Today at 5:30 pm

I am SO sorry I forgot the lynch switch. Usually I'm checking these forums all the time. I just completely forgot yesterday.

I am very surprised that Raiden was town, but I guess that it narrows our list of likely scum candidates.

So as for my reads:

I think it's possible that Saiga is the mafia, but I think it's ONLY possible if Jimmy is his mafia partner. Otherwise, I severely doubt that he is mafia.

Chigusa is null to me. She was pretty active earlier, but now she is much less active. Right before she became inactive she was trying to get Foster lynched, and this counteracts her towniness and reverts her status to null.

Jimmy started out scummy, but is gradually getting less so. It bothers me that he seems to only read the previous page's info instead of getting fully caught up before posting. A possibility to consider is that he is only responding to what he wants to (i.e., only agreeing with his mafia buddy), and for this reason I have him as leaning very slightly scum.

Foster is a mess (no offence). It seems that everything he says is scummy in some way. Because his scumminess is consistent, I think it's more likely that he is just scummy in nature/is struggling to scumhunt, so I think he is also leaning very slightly scummy.

As Saiga said, Lily is very scummy for posting sparsely and lynching without any scumhunting. Therefore, she is very scummy.

Silver seems scummy as well for the same reasons as Lily, but his vacation absolves some of that, so he is leaning scum to me.

Nevermind, Silver is dead :/.

yeah thats kind of the problem with this game, you can scumread everyone lmao

Toran D is online!!!!! Please, help us with our predicament

That's exactly the problem I have with scumreading. Either everyone is suspicious, or nobody is suspicious enough.

How do you want me to help you, exactly? Just my readings?

well, can you rank everybody? top is less scum, bottom is more scum

I guess Jimmy Q. goes quite high on the scumlist, but that's probably what other people are saying subliminally interfering with my judgement.

Saiga Z., you're quite helpful to town. This could be a genuinely helpful townie, or a mafia faking it. Honestly I think the former is more likely, so I'd say you're quite low on the scumlist.

The lurkers are suspiciously lurky, but that could just be them having a lack of things to say at that precise moment. I think they're above average, scumlist wise.

And that's all I can really say. I'll try my best to judge others though.

Interesting, what about Lily. Did you notice anything about her that strikes you weird?

Do you mean the fact that she has:
A) Wanted us to lynch someone inactive.
B) Only lynched as a reason for someone else lynching.

She really wants someone lynched, huh.

yeah, really i would say the only person who should be lynched should be her

infact something striked me just when I typed that post to you, how come lily isnt really with anyone, like there isnt anyone that she could be with. Could she really be with the dead maf Ryuta?

AARRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

this game is driving me mad, I cant keep my cool, I just want AJ to freaking tell me who the maf are lmao

I bet that's a side effect of her inactivity and lurking. When she only posts once per day (not irl day, maf day), it's pretty difficult to connect her with someone.

I would say yes, but that'd most likely be my bad scumreading again.

However, we do have a mislynch, if you're really sure about Lily. But I'm not 100% convinced yet.

Saiga Z. wrote:AARRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

this game is driving me mad, I cant keep my cool, I just want AJ to freaking tell me who the maf are lmao

lol ikr

well I would choose between Lily, Foster, Volt and Jimmy because they really havent been helping town at all. And yes I am starting to get iffy about Jimmy just because he hasnt been helping town progress at all. All he did was defend himself and just agree with everyone. I mean he did talk about a possibility of lynching maf (1/3) but really....I am dont think that helped too much

*I dont