Game 6: Black Flag Nightless

Jeanette C. wrote:Just pointing out that just because I state my opinion, by ALL means think about what I say and ask if it actually makes sense - then you can come up with your own conclusion about your own reads. I don't post to spew gospel, but rather try to come up with discussion topics. By no means are you obligated to agree with what I say (in fact, contesting is more exciting!).

Satchel N. wrote:

Areal I. wrote:

Satchel N. wrote:I read all of Chaz's posts.

They are town

Satchel, no one cares and no one believes you. You are just bandwagoning everyone else's town read on Chaz, and you are scum. You haven't contributed to the conversation, just repeated other people's reads.

The above is what the general consensus on your alignment will be if you don't support the reasoning of your town reads, so please explain why Chaz's posts are town. You can even say somehing like, "Chaz's post are town because, like Jeanette said..." and borrow someone else's reasoning. If you don't star backing up your reads, we will probably have to lynch you.

Well lord, since you ask, you shall receive.

Chaz's scumhunting looks genuine, which is why I townread him.

Satchel N. wrote:Vote: Hajime U.

It has to be this. Everyone else is town.

Satchel N. wrote:

Hajime U. wrote:well i might as well try to vote to spur some more discussion             wait thats been done  , i'm not good at discussion, so i shall flee *Hajime U. Flees*

You know, I really want to policy lynch you for this. but this is too scummy to be scum, I'm reading you as town

1. Satchel: Scum
   He seems particularly reluctant to give us any reasoning for his actions, despite being asked by multiple individuals. This has been his attitude all game, and his repeated defense is that wall posts are not as informative. Well, admittedly you do have to read through longer posts to get the main idea, but not being willing to read is no excuse at all. Even if he is town, there is little benefit to somebody who does not back up their opinions at all, so he wouldn't be helpful in the future. I wanted to point out what Chaz just did - making Hajime the /only/ option was very weird because there are two Mafia remaining. What made you rule out Huromi and Yuriko, then, Satchel? I could see a scumteam of Satchel + one of the other inactives, even Hajime (despite his vote on Hajime).
   
2. Hajime: Leaning Scum
   Also unwilling to give us any information. It seems like several of the active posters in the game significantly lean town, so I could see scum being hesitant to post due to the ease of them being called out when they do slip up. Hajime has even posted that he knows that discussion is going on, but because people are posting he does not want to participate. Like, what? Could be a Village Idiot but also unhelpful either way.  
   
3. Areal: Null, Leaning Scum
   My analysis of the Bailey wagon definitely made me consider Areal as scum. However, wariness of Chaz's plan did not strike me as scummy at the time because the peculiarity of Chaz was on my mind too (I just didn't bring it up because Chaz was just becoming active at that point in the game, and it sounded like he had something interesting going on so I didn't want to disturb). Furthermore, recent interactions makes me think that Areal is just an active townie who likes to question others, and I get the impression that she genuinely cares for this game. Her insistence against the Bailey lynch worries me, though I note that my very early assessment of a possible Areal + Satchel scumteam is looking less likely.
   
4. Yuriko: Null
   Don't really have much on you.
   
5. Huromi: Null
   Nothing on you either. Please speak up.
   
6. Mason: Leaning Town
   Very active in the beginning, has kind of taken a secondary role in the game recently. Mason is involved and brings up logical points when he posts, but he has seemed to be neutral in almost every analysis that he gives. He honestly could be a well hidden scum because nobody particular suspects him - he posts consistently enough with enough content that we don't notice him, but in actuality he does not really bring much of his own opinion to the table. I thought he seemed kinda scummy after the Bailey lynch, but his defense makes me feel slightly better. I might want to do an ISO of Mason later - other's opinions on Mason would be helpful too.
   
7. Chaz: Town
   I liked his plan actually, and his enthusiasm for catching scum. I don't realistically see Chaz being scum at this point, hopefully he isn't pulling the sheep's cloth over my eyes!
   
8. Duplica: Town
   I did an analysis on my Duplica townread earlier, and nothing has changed to make me waver from that point.
   

Areal I. wrote:

Satchel N. wrote:

Areal I. wrote:

Satchel N. wrote:I read all of Chaz's posts.

They are town

Satchel, no one cares and no one believes you. You are just bandwagoning everyone else's town read on Chaz, and you are scum. You haven't contributed to the conversation, just repeated other people's reads.

The above is what the general consensus on your alignment will be if you don't support the reasoning of your town reads, so please explain why Chaz's posts are town. You can even say somehing like, "Chaz's post are town because, like Jeanette said..." and borrow someone else's reasoning. If you don't star backing up your reads, we will probably have to lynch you.

Well lord, since you ask, you shall receive.

Chaz's scumhunting looks genuine, which is why I townread him.

I would like to point out that things aren't always as they seem. Someone's scumhunting could be a way to seem town.

inb4 we lynch hajime and he's maf

Chaz R. wrote:

Satchel N. wrote:

Hajime U. wrote:well i might as well try to vote to spur some more discussion             wait thats been done  , i'm not good at discussion, so i shall flee *Hajime U. Flees*

You know, I really want to policy lynch you for this. but this is too scummy to be scum, I'm reading you as town

This is weird...so you say this guy is town then you go off and say he is the only one who is not town and you have cleared the rest? Dat contradiction tho....

Also, there are 2 mafia but you said he is the only one left. So are you implying that you are the 2nd mafia?

Jeanette C. wrote:My current reads:
Mason: Leaning Town
Very active in the beginning, has kind of taken a secondary role in the game recently. Mason is involved and brings up logical points when he posts, but he has seemed to be neutral in almost every analysis that he gives. He honestly could be a well hidden scum because nobody particular suspects him - he posts consistently enough with enough content that we don't notice him, but in actuality he does not really bring much of his own opinion to the table. I thought he seemed kinda scummy after the Bailey lynch, but his defense makes me feel slightly better. I might want to do an ISO of Mason later - other's opinions on Mason would be helpful too.

Satchel N. wrote:I read huriomi as town, yuriko was town as well ergo?

Obviously I'm missing one scum, but it doesn't matter anyway

Satchel N. wrote:make sure to lynch hajime tommorow

Areal I. wrote:ve been thinking, and I've realized something.

Chaz was deemed town because of his brilliant "plan", right? Well, if he is, by some stretch of the imagination, the mafia, then wouldn't he tell his mafia chum not to mention Bailey? Chaz then could put the blame on someone else, or just reveal his plan and admit no one fell for it. Now, with his defense of Satchel, it is possible that they are the mafia team. Please give your thoughts on this.

It's also possible that one of the inactives completely forgot about the game and hasn't come back. I figure this is also worth mentioning.

Jeanette C. wrote:Mason, if you feel that Hajime would be a better lynch than Satchel, you should... actually lynch Hajime then. I actually have a similar feeling in that Satchel's reaction did not sound that scummy, but in your case you have a vote - why don't you use it?