Search found 9 matches for Mr. Cheeves

Game 31: Separated Scum

It isn't throwing, I don't think I have much to defend myself with~

Game 31: Separated Scum

i'd rather have a vig shoot on mr wilkinson. I dunno, too lazy to read, but I don't like their in and out statement and I do believe they could be traitor os vig. also i admit, i'm probably not as good as contributing to the game so I understand why i would be a decent lynch.

Game 31: Separated Scum

I have nothing to defend against since the o' so powerful "town" leader is pushing against me. Good Luck town and I'd like suggestions on who the vig should kill after I'm lynched. Call me defeatist, but the reasons you're lynching me (like Kodama, saying that by being inactive you'd rather lynch someone who defended themselves the wrong way) aren't ones I approve of.

Game 31: Separated Scum

Ed S. wrote:Mr. Cheeves, there are currently two votes on you: one from myself and one from Magnus. Do you have any comment on these votes or the reasoning behind them?

Also, if you're aware of the wifom surrounding your first paragraph, why go into so much detail with it?

So iirc, Ed S. you lynched me due to the lack of reaction and not commenting on your first post? I'm still unsure why about this one.

And Magnus D. I think that you're lynching me because of the way I handled the first two posts, by subjecting to rvs as a method instead of something else, when I could have easily just lynched you instead. Why I have done these things, I do not know. But I am choosing to abandon the past in hopes of a bright future!

Also I just wanted to explain situations more in depth in case someone didn't have a similar thought process.

Game 31: Separated Scum

First off, I'd like to say that since it's day 1, and no night actions have been used yet, it means that most of these reads are by heart and not by softing inspections and such. So d1 can contrast with many other days to the traitors especially if they get a mafia. If someone flips traitor, using the interactions between d1 and other days, especially if someone gets town read or scum read without a legitimately good reason could be a sign of inspect or buddying. That being said now they'll probably play around what I just said and there was no point in even saying this.

Maria S. wrote:Ed, its true that i dont think RVS can garner truthful reactions. In server mafia, its much more impulsive and fast-paced and so out of the blue lynches can indeed cause scum to slip.

Also, I feel like applying more pressure to people can really cause them to react differently and hopefully slip.

Game 31: Separated Scum

Mr Honcho, having the vig claim would effectively result in the vig clear being dead by the night, as even if they would keep the vig alive for potential misshoots then town would have a clear. It is in my understanding they would try to keep it so that they wouldn't let reads come from a clear. And meanwhile, we can hope that the Traitor Os Vig shoots another traitor instead, leaving us in a better position. As for the questions above,

1) Ed S. There was nothing really I had meant to imply that, just as a joke for lynching each other for no apparent reason.

2) Random Voting Stage? Why would I suggest the idea? Well at that point in time not everyone had talked, and there was no solid evidence to lynch someone. What kind of route would you suggest, Maria? Talking about our roles and what they do would solve nothing except give more strategies on what to do, not who to lynch. And I wholeheartedly support the idea of the vig NOT to claim, as I have explained above. I'd like to hear more on the reasoning to oppose RVS. And for the most part I agree with what you said on your posts, Ed S. but I'd rather leave more freedom to the vigilante to decide who they want to kill. If scum is able to manipulate the vigilante and convince other town members into killing the wrong target, it pretty much guarantees scum the win. So I'm sticking with the thought that if the compulsive vigilante has a strong gutread for whatever reason they should shoot them, instead of an iffy town/scum suggestion.

Game 31: Separated Scum

Hope for the best.

Game 31: Separated Scum

So I do think that Magnus and Ed should keep the whole situation to them self. Meanwhile, let's get started on this beautiful thing called Random Voting Stage. It's a foolproof plan that shall hopefully end up with the result of a power role mafia being lynched.
Vote Rhonda R.

Game 31: Separated Scum

Confirming.