Search found 16 matches for Melanie B.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

aww ;-;

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Alright, the Egan/Aiden discussion is getting us nowhere, basically because it's just Katrina and Mollie going at each other with everyone else watching.

Aiden's seer claim and unclaim can very well have been a failed hypo out of misunderstanding, he claimed seer after the hypo idea was shot down but claims that he didn't realize that we had decided against it before he claimed seer. The main problem is that he never really said that he unclaimed seer, he just thought we assumed he did, which is what caused the controversy. He may just be a/an unlucky/dumb townie, but the whole thing is scummy as hell.

Egan doesn't seem to know what we're even discussing, which is troubling because Mollie is pushing to lynch him. I don't see a whole lot of scumminess in his posts except for the weird readlist in which he reads Akihabara and I as almost confirmed townies and gives town reads on Dr. Yung and Aiden for interesting reasons, Yung for aggressiveness and Aiden for weirdness. I don't see him as my top scumread per se, but he's certainly up there.

I kind of called out Ralph in my last post and he's responded by making better posts with more new content, I don't see him as a townread yet due to this happening right after I brought it up, but I don't feel that he is as scummy anymore. Ralph, you said that you called me out on my inactivity yesterday, but all I see is a read you made noting of it. I'm not really pointing it out as scummy because you were right that I didn't contribute at all yesterday because I was too busy to post, but what you did was hardly calling me out.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Alright, so we lynched the seer. This confirms Katrina as not WW. She could obviously still be mafia, but that's for another day. Captain Aiden seems fairly suspicious for backing out on his seer claim like that, but he might have just failed horribly at hypo. Dr. Akihabara is fairly scummy for being the only lynch on Domenick, although he was admittedly pretty scummy himself.

Im starting to understand the different mindsets people have in anon games and I'm suspecting Ralph to be scum just based on how he's been acting. He was inactive early and was very apologetic, he didn't believe Domenick's seer claim initially, which would explain why a seer claim wasn't targetted night one. He also seems to agree with what everyone else is saying and not adding many new points himself.

If I were to lynch right now it would be either Ralph or Aiden, but I'd like to see some discussion on who everyone else suspects before finalizing anything. I'd especially like to see some activity from inactives such as Egan, Ryou, and Mollie's new sub.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

It's actually 1v2v7, mafia started with 3 members.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Egan G. wrote:I feel its best for ww / mafia to lurk on day 1. they dont wanna draw attention to themselves. Sulllivan, mollie, and ryou are prime targets for the lynch imo.

would like to see them post before i lynch.

Don't know if I fully agree with that strategy, but I do agree that the lurkers should post quite a bit more.

Mollie, you said you would read up and make some gutreads, and came back with an opinion on the seer that had already been brought up. Is that all you've got?

Ryou, you just made your first post that I could see as possibly not being filler. How about you state your opinion on who we should lynch today?

Sullivan, you're being highly considered as a lynch candidate today, maybe you should defend yourself a little?

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Egan G. wrote:h..hi again

i dont have much to say atm. Ephraim M seems to be saying the obvious in giant walls. Dr. A seems towny. Mel B seems towny and kinda cute Dr yung towny and kinda agressive but town read fo sho. Cant get much read on anyone but dominik seem kinda fishy trying the bw lynch on katrina for just acting dumb.

mel b, how do you suggest we talk about hypno if we arent allowed to post our support for it? read minds? cuz i cant do that

If you want to hypo, claim seer and posts your inspects. Don't say, "Oh hypo seems like a good idea" because that just makes hypo dumb because you obviously aren't seer.

Also just realized that my name pretty much is Mel B, spice girls for life

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Typo on akihibara, other people's posts, not lynches.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Early game reads:
Sullivan J.: just a filler lynch on Katrina, nothing to really go off of. Null read.
Melanie B.: is me :3
Dr. Yung: Brings up good points about hypo, leaning town
Ralph I.: No posts since game started. Null.
Katrina K.: Even while messing around, she makes good quality posts when questioned. Leaning town.
Ryou N.: All filler posts so far. Slightly leaning scum.
Egan G.: 2 filler posts, supports the hypo idea which is not the best way to support hypo in the slightest. Leaning scum.
Captain Aiden: Agrees that hypo isn't the best idea, but hypoes anyway? Leaning scum.
Dominick C.: Almost every post is attacking Katrina for shitposting, which is understandable even though she really isn't. Null read.
Ephraim M.: A couple of wall posts trying to dictate how the mafia should play and how hypo he's against hypo. Leaning town.
Mollie H.: Just realized she was in this game. Null read.
Dr. Akihabara: Putting in tons of input on other people's lynches. Leaning town.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Ephraim M. wrote:it's quite simple really, werewolf kills someone at night, we hope it's a mafia, we lynch, hope it's a werewolf, though if we lynch a mafia, and then the next night a town dies, and it goes on like that, we won't have majority over werewolves, and we'll lose, simple. of course lynching a mafia is still better than lynching a town, but it's still bad. it has the effects of a misslynch in a normal game, no positive kill in the day and at night another member of the people voting against the nightkillers will die, it's better to lynch a mafia than lynching a town, but if we're certain someone is mafia rather than werewolf, we've got to ignore it and go for the werewolves instead. Of course this is all situational, I'll work this out a little better later.

Yeah, we have the same idea. I'm just trying to make sure we don't just completely ignore the mafia and let them sneak away with a win.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Oh well, I tried.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Dr. Yung wrote:ephraim made the massive brick wall of ideas lol  but jeez dude, "seer gets WW or not WW" no one can be THAT mentally challenged xD

''

You'd be surprised.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Ephraim M. wrote:A call out to the mafia and town, together we are the town until the werewolves are eliminated, yes it is a BAD thing for town if mafia is killed before the werewolves are eliminated, it's a misslynch, it means we lose 1 vote, and seeing as the mafia and town both have nothing but their votes to use against werewolves, that is a big problem. To the mafia, try not to lynch villagers, to the villagers, try not to lynch mafia. If the mafia and town are any good, they won't be scummy anyways, but it's still something to remember.

I found this idea to be pretty intriguing because it makes the mafia seem as if they're not even a threat right now. At this point there is no doubt that the largest threat is currently the werewolves, but if we lynch a mafia member I'd hardly consider it a mislynch. Depending on how the night kills turn out if we don't end up lynching a mafia, they could win this game just by working to eliminate the werewolves. I'm not saying we should turn our main focus to them, as I said the werewolves are still a much larger threaat, but the mafia are defintely a threat.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

our*

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Being called inactive less than 12 hours into the game. Nice. Btw what should are strategy with the seer be? I guess hypo could work because there's no protecting roles.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Eliza A. wrote:As a professor in "not role-playing" I am going to do no role-play, please understand.

Anyone who demands otherwise will be greeted with a wall of text.

I feel you. I tried role playing once, wasn't for me.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Confirming.