Game 6: Black Flag Nightless

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Black_Flag_Nightless

But yeah clarification please

Jeanette C. wrote:http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Black_Flag_Nightless

But yeah clarification please

Ah, I see.
On another note, i recognized an old friend of mine on that site who I originally introduced to mafia, so that's pretty cool. Its also somewhat funny because I was looking at that thread since I had also searched up the rules for Black Flag Mafia and that thread was the first result (that thread referring to the one linked in the wiki page).

Also, don't just search up Black Flag Mafia, you'll get a bunch of search results about a gang based in New York (which is completely unrelated to this game)

Mason, are we pretty confident that Chaz is town? If so, then after finding Mason/Jeanette/Chaz as town that leaves Duplica, Huromi, and Yuriko to duke it out with each other. The bloodbath for this next phase will be interesting!

I don't think Yuriko will join in.

Lol awkward.

So then Duplica, is it true that you think it is Huromi and Yuriko then?

Well at this point, I am pretty sure the Dupomi team is staring at us in the face.

I'll be frank here, it's possible that it's not only the three of us stated. However, I don't feel that Yuriko is scum just because there is nothing there to be suspicious about. Also, yes. I'm staring you right in your face Chaz, but not with Huromi.

FOS Chaz

FOS?

Finger of suspicion, like what Jeanette used

I see, well my FOS is both Duplica and Huromi

aj, c'mon, if you're gonna be late, be responsible about it.

It was a fun ride, and I have 2nd most posts behind aj! This was such a good time!

Townies! Remeber my advi- X-P

I never mentioned it in the rules, so what Jeanette said doesn't apply.

I honestly thought Areal had a good chance to be scum. She talks in a very suspicious manner sometimes, and there are some evidence that leads to her being mafia.

Back on track though, I feel like a mafia could be lurking and hiding under the trend of the town. I think we need a deep analysis of each person, and requires as much activity from each if of us.

Every decision counts here, and please ask for any clarification on any points I have made.

Wait so if Mafia can only win if 50% of the game is scum, that means that this would not be our last day.

BAH
too soon?

Huromi M. wrote:I honestly thought Areal had a good chance to be scum. She talks in a very suspicious manner sometimes, and there are some evidence that leads to her being mafia.

Back on track though, I feel like a mafia could be lurking and hiding under the trend of the town. I think we need a deep analysis of each person, and requires as much activity from each if of us.

YOU DON'T SAY?!?!?!?!?!?!

Every decision counts here, and please ask for any clarification on any points I have made.

So errr, thanks for pointing out the obvious, as usual. So i have a few scum teams that I would like to list out. The top is most likely and the bottom is least likely

1.) Duplica + Huromi
2.) Duplica + Yuriko
3.) Huromi + Yuriko
4.) Duplica + Jeanette
5.) Yuriko + Chaz (me)
6.) Mason + Yuriko joint with Jeanette + Yuriko
7.) Jeanette + Mason
8.) Jeanette + Chaz (me)
9.) Mason + Chaz (me)
10.) Huromi + Mason

Of course there are others but they are way too unlikely to happen lol. But I would like to point out something, look at the top 5. Lets count how many of each player is listed.

Yuriko = 3
Huromi = 2
Chaz = 1
Duplica = 3

so obviously we can see that the top 5 scum partners have these players as the most common, Duplica and Yuriko. In other words, lynching them means they are most likely mafia. But what do you think guys? At this point using scumhuning maybe good but the fact that we are in LYLO and most of us suck at scumhunting, we need to start to look at probability.

You should list out all 15 possibilities I think, and then we can rank/analyze each onr

Jeanette C. wrote:You should list out all 15 possibilities I think, and then we can rank/analyze each onr

sorry, i am a bit lazy, can you do it please lol. Sorry

First: We do have two lynches (based on what AJ said) so that means we have a pretty good chance of finding the mafia.

Next: here's the possible list.
Players: Jeanette, Chaz, Mason, Duplica, Huromi, Yuriko
Possible teams:
Jeanette and Chaz
Jeanette and Mason
Jeanette and Duplica
Jeanette and Huromi
Jeanette and Yuriko
Chaz and Mason
Chaz and Duplica
Chaz and Huromi
Chaz and Yuriko
Mason and Duplica
Mason and Huromi
Mason and Yuriko
Duplica and Huromi
Duplica and Yuriko
Huromi and Yuriko

Here are the scumlists that I think are possible, based on my reads:
Duplica and Huromi
Duplica and Yuriko
Huromi and Yuriko

I meant scumteams, and not scumlists. Also, by "based on my reads" I essentially put the teams of people I haven't townread (so leaning town would go on the list of possible scumteams)

Also I meant possible lists. There are some groupings that could be discarded without a thought (in my opinion) but some others may think differently, so I have them all there just in case.

Ok sorry, I literally was in the lab the entire day.

Yuriko, since you are here, what do you think about possible scum teams?

I would say that my top 3 scum teams are:
1) Duplica+Huromi (reasoning for this has been stated already by other players)
2) Duplica+Jeanette (You two have been very cooperative, and I think it is possible that the leader of the game could be a mafia)
3) Chaz+Mason (I think these are the two that I meant, they have also been cooperative, and have each had a few scum incidents, e.g: the false plan, and I can't think of anymore right now because I have to leave class now.)
This is what I think right now, and if you have any questions just ask.

Yeah I have a question, how was my false plan scum? It was meant to be false

@Chaz: I know it was meant to be false, but I still think it had a bit of a scum aspect to it.