Game 20: Star-Crossed

not going to debate that it was an easy game though, town was terrible as well

The thing is, the mafia didn't have to try. It's a lot easier, safer, and smarter to let the town sit in a deadzone then pretend to be town and try to stir up activity. We couldn't play well because the town would have to also play well.

so far all games were destroyed by mafia via shit town and luckyish mafia

Game 21 is still going strong

Though they are still bad for lynching me day 2

Sayo R. wrote:The thing is, the mafia didn't have to try. It's a lot easier, safer, and smarter to let the town sit in a deadzone then pretend to be town and try to stir up activity. We couldn't play well because the town would have to also play well.

SURE, YOU DIDN'T HAVE TO TRY
HOWEVER, LOOK AT GAMES 11 AND 7

YOU HAD INACTIVE TOWN THERE, BUT BUTLER AND HARRISON DIDNT DISPLAY THE SAME TRAITS AS YOU AND ROCKY
PERHAPS BUTLER DID A BIT BUT HARRISON DEFINITELY DIDNT

SO SAYING THAT "WE COULDNT PLAY WELL BECAUSE TOWN WOULD ALSO HAVE TO PLAY WELL" IS BULLSHIT AND JUST AN EXCUSE TO BE LAZY
WAS IT A LOT EASIER TO DO NOTHING?
YES.
WAS IT A LOT SAFER TO DO NOTHING?
YES.
WAS IT A LOT SMARTER TO DO NOTHING?
THAT ONE IS DEBATABLE. IT WORKED OUT FOR YOU HERE, BUT HAD ANY COMPETENT TOWN BEEN SUBBED IN, IT WOULD HAVE SCREWED YOU GUYS OVER.

MVP Voting Form if you haven't done so already: http://goo.gl/forms/W48bhCOvMK

ajhockeystar wrote:MVP Voting Form if you haven't done so already: http://goo.gl/forms/W48bhCOvMK

There was an MVP?

I THINK ITS JUST OBLIGATORY, ALTHOUGH THIS ENTIRE GAME WAS TERRIBLE
IM JUST GLAD PEOPLE AGREE WITH ME, SO IM NOT COMPLETELY CRAZY

It's now time for the identities reveals call! I'm going to make a Skype group for the call this weekend, so if you don't have me on Skype and want to be a part of it, PM me in the room with your Skype name! I haven't decided on an exact time yet, I'll do it based on your guys' availability. It'll be this weekend for sure though. See you there!

Player guessing form! http://goo.gl/forms/zi7iObfJME

Jun P.- 0 points
Getting lynched: -3

Keegan G.- 2 points
Getting nightkilled: +1
Being the first nightkill of the game: +1
Being nightkilled as a Vanilla Townie: +1
Being alive for a town mislynch, but not being part of it: -1

Rebecca B.- 0 points
Being the cause of a town death (voting for a mislynch or incorrect vigilante shot): -2
Getting lynched: -3

Kidd C.- 0 points
Being alive for a town mislynch, but not being part of it: -1
Being the cause of a town death (voting for a mislynch or incorrect vigilante shot): -2

Timmy T. #1- 1 point
Each unsuccessful end of day vote against scum: +2
Being alive for a town mislynch, but not being part of it: -1

Timmy T. #2- 0 points
Being the cause of a town death (voting for a mislynch or incorrect vigilante shot): -2

Keith U. #1- 0 points
Being alive for a town mislynch, but not being part of it: -1
Being the cause of a town death (voting for a mislynch or incorrect vigilante shot): -2

Keith U. #2- 0 points
Being named MVP by the mod: +2
Being the cause of a town death (voting for a mislynch or incorrect vigilante shot): -2

Sayo R.- 9 points
Each lynch you participate in that is not a player of your faction: +1
Each night period you live to see: +1 x 2
Winning: +3 per surviving member x 2

Rocky B.- 9 points
Each lynch you participate in that is not a player of your faction: +1
Each night period you live to see: +1 x 2
Winning: +3 per surviving member x 2

I read/skimmed over the game again... I honestly didn't know who to give MVP to. The winners had a combined 5 posts, if you don't count postgame and confirmation posts. Like, even the MVP voting form was troll votes. So I went through all the players and decided to give it to Keith. It was a toss up between him and Keegan, but Keegan decided that he'd say that he "assumed he's dead", which pretty much solidifies for the mafia a kill target. Back to Keith, he was one of two people who actually put effort into this game, once being subbed in, and though he may not have been correct with his reads, he helped town more than any other person in this game. (rip, you still get 0 points)

I SUPPORT THIS CHOICE

For those of you who missed the reveals call, here's everyone's identity from this game!

Jun P. was...:

Keegan G. was...:

Rebecca B. was...:

Kidd C. was...:

Timmy T. #1 was...:

Timmy T. #2 was...:

Keith U. #1 was...:

Keith U. #2 was...:

Sayo R. was...:

Rocky B. was...:

Thanks to everyone for playing, hope you enjoyed, and hope to see you next time!