Search found 29 matches for The Rodman

Anita B. wrote:Hello folks! Now that we've started, I figure we can just do this properly, after the usual d1 Bs ofc.

So I'd like to see what everyone's thoughts on me lynching Horatio A or Penelope C?

Why would you immediately throw shade on you partner? This is supporting Penelope if/as town

Kylan R. wrote:Anyways Anita and Professor for early scum team.

Lynch Professor Jacuzzi for being a selfquoting scumbag with a much more prophetic beard than I.

Although, Kylan threw some shade at Anita, while actually avoiding the lynch. Kinda sketchy to me, because this can be either supporting Kylan or Penelope, but I would say mostly supporting penelope

Anita B. wrote:
Sanpei S. wrote:You don't just ask us our thoughts on you lynching people.

You lynch them, and then see what we think. God.

Unlynch Professor Jacuzzi, Lynch Anita B.

Asking us to "approve" your lynch seems like a scummy thing to do, no? It's as though you're mafia asking town what to do so you can try to fit in better.

Can confirm I'm Mafia with professor jacuzzi

Lynch Penelope C

Again, Anita actually hit Penelope with a lynch d1 for no reason. I see it pointless for scum to risk people hopping on a random turbo.

Anita B. wrote:
The Rodman wrote:Did you claim mafia partners with Prof. Well I belive it.

Lynch Anita B

Interestingly enough, I'm pretty sure your just bandwagoning because turbo.

I say we lynch Penelope C. today bc apparently she's superior to everyone else and I hate egotistical players

Pls do not call me selfish because this kinda helps me out too, but when pressured by me, Anita offered a lynch on Penelope. Why would either: A) Scum lynch partner d1 for towncred or B) Tell a townie to lynch their partner,(or) UNLESS Kylan was their partner, and was directing town to lynch town (if you didnt get the gist either way it put Kylan as scummy)

Anita B. wrote:
Rhyanna F. wrote:What are everyone's thoughts on Anita's reactions, btw?

Answer that

Unlynch, Lynch The Rodman

I like Sanpei's reasoning for keeping Penelope alive (egotistical players tend to slip is what I read it as, however I may have missed the meaning)

k so I'm gonna pressure Roddy here, idc if it's omgus.

The Rodman, Why jump on my Lynch?

Also, if this is a bit early but, if I'm not scum, who do you think it is?

I'm going to post a bit more in a minute

Rhyanna F. wrote:the quality of rodman's posts were irrelevant to my townread on him. He lynched anita immediately on day 1, and Anita legitimately tried to go after him (switching to horatio/penelope when this failed). I doubt that they'd both be bussing that hard, which makes me very certain that rodman is town. Try to get past your own biases of him having low quality posts and the point should make sense.

Anita lynched me back (dont even tell me its scum 1v1 bus war) and after failing to get back on me why would you try and gain traction by getting you partner lynched

Again, pls tell me of any other imperfections. Ik a lot of this refers to d1 but that was the time when scum and rest of the game were actually relative with both partners being alive. To me Kylan is scum over Penelope but I wanna see what you guys have to say. Not just "Ya Rodman is scum" (kylan).

Game 29: Guess Who?

Also, I cannot spend anymore of my time today formulating reads because I am overwhelmed with school work. Tomorrow when I am free will be my return.

Game 29: Guess Who?

Oh wow I am absolute trash for not seeing it was town>scum. My apologies, and now I acknowledge that certain point actually works against me.

Game 29: Guess Who?

Why so?

Game 29: Guess Who?

How ironic how now I am the one waiting for a response

Game 29: Guess Who?

Rhyanna F. wrote:That would be Carl.
ATM town->scum for me is:
Rodman -> Sanpei -> Manning -> Penelope -> Carl -> Kylan -> Horatio/PJ

So here Kylan is put at 2nd highest scum read by rhyanna. keep this in mind as i go along

Rhyanna F. wrote:also kylan just got subbed yet was apparently inactive during the night phase, meaning that he couldnt have sent in the kill unless he was subbed in during the night and aj only told us that he was subbed now to prevent suspicion
i could be looking into it way too much but its something to consider

i feel like even i am over analyzing this, but if i read this right, kylan #1 was inactive when rhyanna was on, then kylan #2 sent kill, and finally aj tried to make it look like activity was irrelevant to possible roles.
So um, if thats the case it could be putting kylan as scum in our situation.

Rhyanna F. wrote:Kylan>Penelope>Rodman>Carl is my current town>scum
me not getting nightkilled makes me think rodman COULD be a viable scum but i'm not certain that that's the case since I don't think Anita was smart enough to do a weak bus on day 1

another situation where rhyanna, the most townie had kylan at top lynch priority. In addition, Kylan's locktown reads on rhyanna (and penelope) couldve been an attempt to get on her goodside, even tho it was obvious rhyanna was town (even to me from d1) and the read was redundant.

Rhyanna F. wrote:Anita B. wrote:

I have a town read on Carl G, Rhyanna F., Professor Jacuzzi and Ian S.. Carl G I've had a town read on this entire game, and that's the exact reason I didn't ask him to "come back" like Jacuzzi and Horatio got triggered by. His first post gives him a townish presence, whilst his secondary post is just overall useful towards reads and their reasoning imo. Rhyanna F. has been constantly scumhunting, trying to incite discussion and overall helping town on their way. Jacuzzi whilst he's active has been useful, and created the first "good" post explaining why I'm scum. Ian S. has just been overall helpful this entire game after learning it existed, which is good.

I'm neutral on Sanpei S., because yes he's been jumping and helping discussion, he's very flippant with his lynches and Imo it seems like he doesn't care who dies. I could just be bad though

Rodman is neutral bc I got nothing on him. Manning is also neutral bc he comes back, but doesn't do too much with his comeback post, simply stating reads but not much reasoning for it. However, he doesn't hammer me, which as scum, would've been the easiest thing to do. (Following that logic, I feel like scum has to be someone inactive or already on my lynch)

Horatio A. is p scummy because it feels more like he's just spitting back out reasoning others have used and hasn't done anything much else otherwise. However, I may have missed something.

Accidentally deleted the part where she goes after Penelope but it feels like it's a similar situation with Rodman, where she goes after someone and then switches her target when no other lynches follow. I think Anita was just throwing out a ton of lynches to see what would stick (which means i'm fairly certain Penelope is town too).
it's relevant that both Ian and Carl are moved to the townpile despite not posting anything of use between her last post (where they werent in the townpile) and this one.
She also doesn't mention Kylan. This means one of two things: 1) She forgot about Kylan like the rest of us, or 2) Kylan's her scumpartner and she didn't mention him to avoid there being any connections between the two of them, knowing that we wouldn't be paying much attention since Kylan was basically gone at that point

As Rhyanna points out Anita threw lynches at Penelope and I, while evading Kylan; lynches just to see if people would go for the d1 randlynch bait. While it is very possible Anita did forget about Kylan, it also couldve been in hopes that people didnt take the d1 randlynch bait on their scumpartner.

All this is against Kylan, so later I will backread for stuff on Penelope. Albeit, these give Kylan a pretty good reason to try and get Rhyanna to town read him after all the heavy scumreads, but have to end up killing her after fruitless attempts.

P.S. please correct me if anything is out of context because I did not quote these in chronological order, and yes ik im pretty stupid for that.

Game 29: Guess Who?

the reason i posted that before lylo was because I thought the other players in the game would do better than me

Game 29: Guess Who?

Also, if some of you feel I am useless, you may as well lynch me to have better players in LyLo

Game 29: Guess Who?

Honestly I feel like I am a very useless player. Even on PS I backpack off my fellow townies, and as far as reads go, I have never been the type to have actual reasons. I have primarily based the majority of my lynches off of gut feeling and reading the way people talk. I can also see how I can be the "sit back in the shadows guy", but I assure you when I am mafia I make an effort to be active and "townie". So it is very hard to townread me or scumread me because when I am close to being townread, my lack of reason makes me look scummy. So far everyone of my town reads, and 1 scum read have died (Manning). Honestly I still feel Carl as I have mentioned before, but I am fearful that my town read (Rhyanna) could be really good scum.

Game 29: Guess Who?

Manning P. wrote:the rodman, horatio, penelope and jacuzzi were all pretty quick to jump on anita.
in the rodmans case he posted nothing else apart from the random bandwagon on her, and that penelope and jacuzzi used the same post as the basis for their read on her.
while sanpei lynched her and then unlynched he provided original reasoning when he did lynch her which i value more over the lengthy posts the others made with partly reused arguments.
on the other hand having looked at her defense its basically just wifom plus another few reads... which is not to my liking and hence i want to keep the pressure.
i shall lynch anita and put her at l-1.

honestly i just feel like this was an example of the realization that the partner (if scum) was being without a doubt lynched at the end of the day.

I'll pop on tonight for a bit to maybe look at some past posts from people and see if my mind changes at all, but expect a Anita lynch from me.(Carl G.)

that was end of day 1. So on one hand I see it as a last minute attempt to detach from your partner while on the other hand I see someone who made it look like they thought Anita was scum without actually lynching them. The latter reasoning is one I have seen come true many times on PS. But I will proceed to abstain so i can hear from anyone

Game 29: Guess Who?

IDK how scum would frame me if I was the one looking at Sanpei as scum. And I agree with how it's surprising that Rhyanna has not died considering they are the most townie out of anyone to me. As for today, I will not lynch yet because I am deciding between Carl and Manning. I rule out Kylan because I cannot actually read him and Horatio is townie to me.

Game 29: Guess Who?

Uh ya sorry I have been really busy with school and sports getting home around 10pm everyday. Albeit, I do sort of agree with Rhyanna's reasoning of Prof. Jacuzzi I do not think repeating a method of preservation is really scummy because it is still preservation. If I had to guess scum rn it would be Sanpei because of what I see as evasiveness. While you could argue I'm pretty evasive as well, I think next week won't be too stressful for me.

Game 29: Guess Who?

Please do not base thoughts on anything I said before page 7 because that was someone else. I am a sub for that player.