Search found 14 matches for Ralph I.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

my read was sorta on point ayyy. ty ww you're a bro to be honest, helped us so much for late game stuff, really. only 1 of each party left so let's get going. imma do the same as ryou tomorrow when I wake up and make up a bit of a detailed readlist at the very least, and i didn't get much of a chance to jump on to the forums for the lynch yesterday, sorry about that. anyway, I'd recommend a reads list everyone, that would greatly aid us at this stage, we're pretty damn close to the win right now, i can smell it.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Ryou N. wrote:I don't really like subbing. I'm better with reads when I watch the action "live" and then possibly read than when I dig through pages of text but here goes.

Aiden - just plain weird. Admits to trying to initiate a hypo when the general consensus was that it's a bad idea, goes inactive, then admits a bad play to explain himself. Weird weird weird.

Ralph I. - His early activity had strong "Katrina is shitposting" content, then he agrees with her logic, then argues with her again. Doesn't lynch, lets plurality happen... tries to sit in the backgroud.

Katrina K. - Town read, sound logic. I don't get why Seer would inspect her though... a waste of an inspect, if she is Scum, then she is Mafia.

Egan G. - chaotic, random and bad accusations towards Epihraim, pushing a lynch on Dominick...

Melanie B. - She does seem intent on protecting Aidan. No one is interested in protecting WW at this point though... And I sort of agree with her on Aidan acting like a Village Idiot.

Mollie H. - I don't really like sudden jump on Katrina but that might be because she's my Town read.

Dr A. - No solid read.

Lynch Ralph I., my strongest scum read at this point.

i guess here's my argument. you could have read all my posts btw and seen that i had my reasons for not lynching btw, it's not hard to see that. For further clarification, I didn't lynch because I felt that both Aiden and Dominick were incredibly vague and stuff at that point, and other than that post from katrina, which honsstly didn't help my read much, they were pretty good lynches. i felt that i shouldn't lynch for that reason and that someone else should lynch instead and make the decision. also, people can have differing and similar opinions, so i dont get how the fuck the katrina argument rrally applys that much. acting a bit aggressive and questioning logic is my style, what can i say? as i said before, I'm a bit of a nuisance, and you can lynch me if you want, i wouldn't mind that. But I've been contributing a whole lot more and actually trying to get some solid reads on folks here, so I'd say that I'm thr wrong lynch for today at least, especially with the information that we have currently against some folk.

as i said earlier, ask me questions, and make me actually givr you guys information if im being vague or not filling in the areas you need to understand, im happy to do so. will lynch later on tonight.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

reminder that we only have a day or so left and it would be nice to talk about stuff. we were doing so well activity wise. Anyway, I was reading the dead scums posts and was noticing how both sullivan (in his readslist) and yung were basically dismissing/not bringing egan into the analysis at that stage. I hadn't even noticed this until now (more on sullivans part where he just says he's in agreeance with egan but doesn't tell us anything about him, unlike everyone else where he has at least a separate part (not me and mollie but at that point we had done fuck all tbh)). I'm not sure what to think of this at this stage, whether this was just conincidence (more likely since two separate factions), or one or the other is trying to ignore him and slip that under the radar. Not a concrete bit of information, just wanted to share that to see what you guys thought. also, please actually comment on shit and bring up new topics, can't believe I'm the one needing to say that, but we need some talking going on and we need to start soon with it.

(also holy hell my english is terrible in the last post. i blame mobile early in the morning.)

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Captain Aiden wrote:Alright, ngl I said I was going to "reread" Day 1, but I didn't expect to be so busy. Sorry I can't be on more. From my perspective, I thought hypo was a fine idea (btw I make all my posts at 2AM so never the best plays). So I claimed Seer to "initiate" hypo. It was a really bad play. Mollie is right, it was a failed hypo attempt.

You did say that you u meant to retract as well on day two which made me a bit plausible about the Katrina stuff. Honestly I'm not sure at this point. Our twp lynch targets imo are fine candidates at the moment in time (leaning aidan more than egan right now, but i won't lynch quite yet.) and i think that if we drive a bit more activity today we can get some stuff done. Auite honestly, I'm skrt of wanting to hear thing from our lynch targets at this stage to see where they're at with things, as it would be nice to see their pov.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Katrina K. wrote:Ralph, I was referring to Dominick's tunnel on me Day 1. Although I can see how you may have confused it as me referring to you. Also I meant you could have changed the lynch because you posted after I did thus you are the only person that can be confirmed to have had the opportunity to read my post before the deadline. I legit stated that I thought Dominick was town and that we should have lynch Captain Aidan through valid points. You decided not to lynch Aidan letting plurality hit Dominick, costing us our seer.

Ahh I see. And understandably, there were like 3 hours til deadline or so from my post. Both Aiden and Dom had been fairly vague so I hadn't really felt my decsion on a lynch was conclusive, in terms of my reads at that point and that I thought that one of our other players could place this lynch, someone who actually had an idea on the best lynch. I did read your evidence btw, but I still felt they were both rather odd and either would've been a good lynch target.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Melanie B. wrote:Alright, so we lynched the seer. This confirms Katrina as not WW. She could obviously still be mafia, but that's for another day. Captain Aiden seems fairly suspicious for backing out on his seer claim like that, but he might have just failed horribly at hypo. Dr. Akihabara is fairly scummy for being the only lynch on Domenick, although he was admittedly pretty scummy himself.

Im starting to understand the different mindsets people have in anon games and I'm suspecting Ralph to be scum just based on how he's been acting. He was inactive early and was very apologetic, he didn't believe Domenick's seer claim initially, which would explain why a seer claim wasn't targetted night one. He also seems to agree with what everyone else is saying and not adding many new points himself.

If I were to lynch right now it would be either Ralph or Aiden, but I'd like to see some discussion on who everyone else suspects before finalizing anything. I'd especially like to see some activity from inactives such as Egan, Ryou, and Mollie's new sub.

said by the lady who gave us zilch day 2. thanks again for being such a great contrubtor to the town's effort yesterday and appearing when i call you out at end of day 2.

honestly, if you guys want to lynch me, do it. im playing terribly and clearly clouding judgement here. my readslist were my thoughts alone, and i can't really help thr fact that t I've not really been active enough to bring up really new things before you guys do. on that front, i have school, so i can't help that much. can say I'm vanilla townie at this point, and I'll definitely be sure to try and do some deeper analysis in the future. Sorry for being a shit and reallly vague guy this time around.

Katrina K. wrote:
Mollie H. wrote:I'm actually really suspicious of Dr. A and Katrina for their lynching yesterday. There was nothing about Dominick's play which screamed anything but town and I think that lynching him was only mafia-minded. However, that's not the main target today. The main target is Lynch Egan G. because I have no doubt in my mind that he is anti-town, and I think there is a strong chance he is werewolf. He has not done a single town-minded thing this whole entire game and is the epitome of playing under the radar. His posts have been wishy washy in general and I don't like it at all.

Oh hi, BTW! I actually hate subbing into games most of the time, but in this case I think it benefitted me to read the whole thread in one go because I could see tendencies and patterns a bit better. For the record, Melanie is a hugely strong town read for me and I think everyone else. If you're mafia/werewolf you basically deserve the win. IMO we sure don't after the abysmal showing yesterday, but if we pick up our game maybe we can make this all worthwhile. What do y'all say?

>my lynching yesterday.

sure I lynched Dominick rather early, but then I changed my lynch once I realized that he was very unlikely to be scum, which i stated. Either way, I posted my change in lynch with a good amount of time before the deadline, and Ralph could have changed their lynch at any given point. He also did have a major tunnel vision that was based off terribad logic which you woulda seen if you really read his reasoning.

I have also stated that I found E gang scummy early on but I'm not pushing the lynch on him because I didn't find it likely that he was WW, which is our priority to find since they are the only ones who can nightkill. So my question is why, other than his general scumminess makes you believe he is more likely to be WW than the damn cc to the dead seer. And then might I also ask why would I change my lynch in the middle of the day like that? We had plurality on the seer so why would I change my vote to the non-seer when I said it is a better move for mafia to eliminate the seer in that situation? And I even stated in my change of lynch post that I had reason to believe he was seer. Plus you don't seem to realize how scummy Dominick was coming off to town and apparently the mafia too. iirc Dr. Yung had a scum read on Dominick too. And its not like we can't trust a mafia's read rn because it could at least help us figure out the WW.

That abysmal showing yesterday was merely cause of a lack of activity as can be attested to by your own subbing in. Honestly if people had been more active, we might have actually lynched the Werewolf -cough- Captain Aiden -cough- Don't push blame off of the person you subbed or the people who were inactive. It was kinda Mollie's (the entity not neccesarily the person who is Mollie rn) fault too. You also can't attest to mafia being careful because some mafia are generally scummy as hell... Look at Kuroyo in Game 15.

Also the point I was making was that Captain Aidan was Werewolf, not mafia. Mafia would be retarded to claim seer when there was only one other claim, as I stated before. And then theres that immediate retract once I pressured Aiden for his inspects, which was scummy as hell. EVERYONE in the history of hypo knows not to retract their claim unless theres a scum inspect, or its Day 3/4 in a 15p game of classic.

If you bothered to read carefully, and take more time to think logically you would see that my point is at least valid, and unless you can provide us some more reasoning as to why E gang is WW, besides his general lurkiness and wishy washiness, I suggest we lynch Aidan.

Also let me just say this... you don't want to start a war with me. I will ban you from the cookie sales list. You will never be able to buy my cookies again. For real though, I can shut a person down real quick. Especially since I have been more helpful in finding scum than the original Mollie who was quiet and fillery.

katrina, when you said about my lynch on here, i didn't even lynch once this game so far, so i don't see where this logic is coming from. also there's the fact I was apparently tunnelvisioning in that post? load of bullshit seeing as i haven't been focusing on one guy so far too much. in my reads list, i don't see one piece of evidence in it that shows me tunnelling. would love to see what you saw me doing that was tunnelling, seeing as I can't. You may have a really misconstrued definition of it, but I knoe i haven't been doing so.

will check on this more frequently I guess, feel free to ask me questions.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

readlist time! also ephraim i said I'd do it today so please don't jump on me like that, still like 4 or so hours til deadline? maybe like 8 from your post time? I'm not sure on timezones, anyway, here we go.

Melanie B. - had content day 1, good content at that, and then just flatout stopped. I'm not sure if she is lurking, doesn't have anything to say, or is inactive, but it's worrying seeing how she was a decent player before hand. null, i can't make my mind up.

Ralph I. - obvious scum, why the heck are people not lynching him oml xD

Katrina K. - strong town lean, Katrina has very sound logic and has been a great aid to the town imo. She has been helpful in driving discussions, hasn't had any conflicts in her posts from what I've seen atm, but i wouldn't count that side out yet, just had a skim. Kat is definitely high up on my readlist.

Ryou N. - no comments on him, new sub. old guy seemed to filler a bit, but i can't really nitpick much since this guy might change my opinion. null.

Egan G. - honestly has been rather lurky at times. slight scum lean, he's not really giving us much to run on and i think he's been doing a tiny bit of filler here and there as well. ironic seeing as he calls out someone on it.

Captain Aiden - null, pretty barren post wise, will have to see his readlist to see his ideas.

Dominick C. - i have no idea really about dom. thing i dont get is why isn't he dead yet if he was like the one really prominent seer claim early on. he's been pretty quiet today. would love to see a readlist from you as well, that would be nice and helpful for us all.

Ephraim M. - slight town read, but kats list of sullivans views have swayed me a little bit to a more town lean. definitely not werewolf at least, as i don't get why you would bus your partner through a readlist on day 1 and whilst being the faction with the upper hand (night action).

Mollie H. - why the heck is mollie not subbed. literally nothing from her and it would be nice to get someone who could give us something here. null.

Dr. Akihabara - slight town, im feeling like aki is a good member of the game atm. he's been extremely active and has been a great contributor in terms of quality of his arguments, his ideas, and strategy. not been analysing him much, but I'm gonna keep an eye on him anyway, need a more solid read imo.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

apparently a post I put in yesterday didn't come thru, but anyway, good job guys, that nightkill will really help us late game :]

good shout katrina by the way, I'm honestly agreeing with your line of thinking here, it's very logical.

I think I'm going to either make a readlist at the end of day 2 or by the start of day 3, as a lot of people are still a bit vague and I need a tad more information about some people in the game, as well as some extra analysis.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Ephraim M. wrote:Ralph, the relevance of the nightkill for the werewolves was in that you gave them ideas for targets, you were talking about who could possibly be the seer, and that's a bad idea.

Ahh, I get where you're coming from there. Hadn't really thought of that. Still doesn't outrule them however. I just suggested a possibility that the guy could be hypoing which had already been suggested I'm pretty sure. It's not certain, and I certainly didn't give our a shoutout saying: "this guy is definitely seer folks", because, I clearly didn't.

Sorry for coming off a bit brutish if I have been, I just want to get my point across in a quick fashion, after all, we only have so long to discuss and make ground to get rid of the scum factions.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Katrina K wrote:
Ralph I. - Ephraim had a point earlier when saying to leave the nightkill up to the wolves to decide. You may have just made it THAT much easier for them to kill the seer. good job there buddy. Also ectremely inactive, and has made only two posts since the game started. His posts havent been all that helpful either.

I think its a bit bloody obvious that the nightkill is up to the werewolves, sinc ethey have the only bloody kill in the game. I don't get why you had to put that lil tidbit from ephraim in there, it wasn't relevant as far as I'm concerned. Also not really Katrina, I'm just explaining that the talk about hypo is useless now that you guys suggested it. A true hypo that would work would be unannounced, and saying 'lets go and hypo' isn't helping that front. I gave 2 informative posts, and had stated before that I could not help the fact that I didn't know that the game started. Also, there's the fact that post numbers are inflated a lot due to the 9 pages before the game started, so you've made like, what, 6 posts probably? maybe 8 realistically? I'll agree that I've not posted much but come on, I'm not that inactive, I'm giving information here.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Egan G. wrote:
Melanie B. wrote:
Egan G. wrote:h..hi again

i dont have much to say atm. Ephraim M seems to be saying the obvious in giant walls. Dr. A seems towny. Mel B seems towny and kinda cute Dr yung towny and kinda agressive but town read fo sho. Cant get much read on anyone but dominik seem kinda fishy trying the bw lynch on katrina for just acting dumb.

mel b, how do you suggest we talk about hypno if we arent allowed to post our support for it? read minds? cuz i cant do that

If you want to hypo, claim seer and posts your inspects. Don't say, "Oh hypo seems like a good idea" because that just makes hypo dumb because you obviously aren't seer.

Also just realized that my name pretty much is Mel B, spice girls for life

and now dominik has claimed seer. He either put a huge target on his back or is trying to take the pressure off of him. Time will tell.

also Katrina K. seems mad that i can talk to the cute mel b and she cant post lolicon without people thinking that shes mentally handicapped.

I think its highly unlikely that Dom is a seer. would be pretty surprised if he was one imotbh. I could picture him just waiting to take a. lil bit of pressure off the rest of the town tonight and see if he can bait some people. of course that's just one of many possibilities and there could be other reasons for the claim, just my thoughts. also as stated above, saying let's do hypo means the hypo is redundant as fuck.Hypo is pointless now and should be put on the back burner now that someone mentioned the word hypo, given the fact that the point of hypo is to get rid of certainties that could aid scum, without really giving that away.

(Also for god's sake Katrina can you stop the lolicon bullshit? flavour/useless filler isn't really aiding us and it would be nice for me not have to edge over areas of your posts because you get off topic and talk about lolicons.)

Game 18: Jungle Republic

Apologies for not posting yet, I completely forgot this was happening, thought we wouldn't have started quite yet. Anyway I do think that we should not just be jumping into his game with lynches firing off. As said by doc aki, the way we scumhunt is the difference between us winning or losing here. IMO mafia will likely lie as villager styled outlook through the game, as it would be eumb for them not to do that, seeing as they don't have a massive pull of power of the game, unlike werewolf etc, with their kill. that would be if they were playing it safe of course, I couldn't really tell what could happen this game. Anyway I'm gonna read on some stuff and come back in an hour I think to comment on that.

Game 18: Jungle Republic

the level of shitposts even before we start is ridiculous this time around., in both games. At least we're all gonna have decently active games I guess?

Game 18: Jungle Republic

confirmed.