Search found 12 matches for Eileen J.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

LUCARIO, USE AURA SPHERE!

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Great Game Guys!!!!!

I died early on but it's fine, really.
I thought doc would wanna protect me but I understand why he would doubt me since the same thing happened with romeo from game 9. At least we got the win!

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Incoming contentless bah post

bah!!!

Good luck guys :3

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Well i don't want to seem as i am taking over town or brainwashing the town, but to scum hunt we must deeply question people's thoughts and arguments.

Also, this may seems scummy, but I don't see why lynching me is the best option today. I respect your opinions tho.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Lily G. wrote:
Eileen J. wrote:
Raiden Y. wrote:Ok just want to say a few things:

a)Eileen people random lynched because right now we have no leads and people are fishing for any slip from mafia to pressure them.

b)On a game without cop(omg yes scumhunting #1) We only have 1 option to win the game which is scum hunting. It's the 1st day so obviously there will be little to go off but instead of saying that we need to create discussion for example i really liked what saiga did about asking what eileen thoughts were.

I was never against random lynching in the RVS stage, I just wanted to see the reasonings on why they picked a particular person to "random" lynch and build on from that. When the death is revealed, we can then find out the intention of the person that started the lynch.

I agree that questioning other thoughts like Saiga did but of course before that we at least need to start a simple discussion to analyze and build upon.

Who do you think is the best lynch option?

Someone who is inactive so their feelings don't get hurt!

Well, many people are inactive at the moment, so I don't think that will work too well. Also, as someone has pointed out, we gain no information from them. Are you just trying to get a lynch off you?

Also @Foster U., I don't really mind if you lynch someone because that does starts up discussion and there was no need to unlynch him. The problem with your lynch is that I don't really like your "why not" because it doesn't necessary starts up constructive discussion.

As the game progress it would be nice if we can do a "read" or an analysis of player by player to hopefully catchscum or see similarities.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Raiden Y. wrote:Ok just want to say a few things:

a)Eileen people random lynched because right now we have no leads and people are fishing for any slip from mafia to pressure them.

b)On a game without cop(omg yes scumhunting #1) We only have 1 option to win the game which is scum hunting. It's the 1st day so obviously there will be little to go off but instead of saying that we need to create discussion for example i really liked what saiga did about asking what eileen thoughts were.

I was never against random lynching in the RVS stage, I just wanted to see the reasonings on why they picked a particular person to "random" lynch and build on from that. When the death is revealed, we can then find out the intention of the person that started the lynch.

I agree that questioning other thoughts like Saiga did but of course before that we at least need to start a simple discussion to analyze and build upon.

Who do you think is the best lynch option?

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Saiga Z. wrote:
Eileen J. wrote:Uhh I can't seem to collect all my thoughts in one post but I promise this will be the last one for now.

Since there are two mafia teams, it is to be expected that this game will be rather quick. Assuming we lynch a townie today and the both ice and fire mafia succeeded in their kills, we already have 3 townie down. (Correct me if I'm wrong.)

For now though, Lynch Foster U.

I don't really like your "hasn't talked yet and why not" argument as it seems like you don't really care who you votes out at this moment. If you provide a logical argument, I may consider unlynching you.

what are your thoughts on me and that other guy who random voted.

I think that the first 2 votes were purely random and are just discussion starters. I am suspicious of foster because i did not like his attitude toward the lynch.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Uhh I can't seem to collect all my thoughts in one post but I promise this will be the last one for now.

Since there are two mafia teams, it is to be expected that this game will be rather quick. Assuming we lynch a townie today and the both ice and fire mafia succeeded in their kills, we already have 3 townie down. (Correct me if I'm wrong.)

For now though, Lynch Foster U.

I don't really like your "hasn't talked yet and why not" argument as it seems like you don't really care who you votes out at this moment. If you provide a logical argument, I may consider unlynching you.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Also if I recall correctly there is no cop in this format so all the information we receive will be from the doc, which won't reveal anyway. Therefore our most powerful way of getting information is through lynching and logical scum hunting.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

I don't really know what to say or start a discussion this early in the game, but I just wanted to point out that in the beginning scum will probably act as innocent as possible especially when no one have questioned them yet. Therefore, we shouldn't make any quick conclusions that anyone is scum or town just from their first reactions.

Sorry if this post was rather obvious but I just wanted to start a discussion since it's rather quiet at the moment.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

So I'm seeing that we have started to random lynch people, without much reasoning behind it. It would be nice if you could explain why you have chosen that person in particular.

I would prefer to hold my lynch for now, and lynch a person that seems scummy, trollish or inactive because they're never useful to town.

Game 8: Fire and Ice Mafia

Confirmed.