Search found 101 matches for Butler P.

Game 12: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

I love how everyone got rssp1 except for Pie who said "Fort?"

Points Leaderboard

Mizuho N. wrote:Wow.... Vex plays 2 games and gets 31 points. I play 6 games (excluding Game 3, 4 and 10) and only get 29.....

Bow down, bow down.

(I'll probably be town next game and get lynched day one or something.)

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Mickey L. wrote:also smh aj, I attempt to change it up but I can't help but lead town IF NOBODY ELSE IS ACTIVE >_>
Also dang, I was wondering who igpay was, surprised to see it was Rochelle.

Uh...I helped lead the town

Points Leaderboard

Also, broke that record that I was one short of braking last time. .3.

Points Leaderboard

31 Points, tied for third with champ who has 14 points. Seems legit.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

"We're so screwed" ~Butler, 2014

As you can see, I had utmost confidence in this game.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

I knew Gizelle was Citrus Freak when he PM'd me in a game that I was hosting saying he wanted to try something called "suicide scum-hunting."

He and rssp1 were the only ones I got right in this game. When Trinity kept talking about time zones I was sure she was Singapore, but I forgot about PikaCal. I also guessed that the only active Fergus was Fort, but turns out I was only half right.

I also guessed Kaito as Spieky. Urgh MyWay... >_>

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Oh AJ, are you gonna post the scum quick topic?

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Wow MyWay, what a troll.

Man, I keep getting mafia in these. Maybe no one notice my posting style in Anon games in the future and compare me to Julie and Butler. xD

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Natchi F. wrote:smh you game 11 people weren't able to get it together. I was counting on you guys so that mafia wouldn't sweep this round.
Ah well, GG mafia!

Maybe you should get your own town together before you start complaining about game 11's.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Mizuho N. wrote:
Makino C. wrote:Also mfw Game 12 invades our game and talks about the screw ups they made instead of doing it in their own game smh.
I mean WE only invaded to congratulate the winners, you guys came here to make our players feel worse about themselves ~~sadists y/y?~~

M9, we are trying to makr your game more active you should be grateful smh smh.

We were only giving our views on your game, not trying to make you seem bad....

Pfft, all I can see is talk about your own game.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Mizuho N. wrote:
Butler P. wrote:
Mickey L. wrote:I got drookez right.

Unless Drookez isn't playing.

No drookez is most definitely playing (hint hint he may or may not be me)

Ah yes. I forgot about the numerous times you hinted during the game that you were Sir Drookez. *cough cough*

Sorry, I seem to have a bit of a cold.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Mickey L. wrote:I got drookez right.

Unless Drookez isn't playing.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Yes! Excellent job Makino. Great game to everyone, it was quite enjoyable. It was rather anticlimactic though.

Fun fact: Kaito sent the kîll via PS to Aj without even talking to me or Makino.

I am greatly anticipating the player guessing

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

This is possibly the last chance I have to get online before deadline, so because of that, I will go ahead and place my kynch.

Lynch Rochelle

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Trinity M. wrote:
Butler P. wrote:I believe I have made my stance on Rochelle clear. I am currently leaning towards her.

Butler, what are your thoughts on fergus atm? I'm personally leaning on him, just curious if you had a view about it.

Argh...I mean, it did seem desperate when he said that Makino was the scummiest person in the town for the entire thing about not addressing a townies death. I'm not sure if he still believes that, but he did say say that he thought you and Makino were a scum team. I can't formulate a full opinion on him until he posts his reasoning why he thinks Trinity + Makino is the team, which based on his last post doesn't seem likely to happen in the next 5 hours.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

I believe I have made my stance on Rochelle clear. I am currently leaning towards her.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Rochelle R. wrote:
Butler P. wrote:
Rochelle R. wrote:N33T, Kaito turned mafia.
I understand I'm not off the hook. In my defense, I was actually pressured into taking off the lynch from Kaito, and it would have been easy to preserve Kaito had I wanted to.

Yes, it would have been easy to preserve Kaito had you wanted to. You merely had to unlynch him. How does this defend you, exactly?

Also, Toran D. was only subbed out once. See game 8, page 31.

See, here it seems to me that you didn't take into account the first sentence. Idk, I thought this was clear. It seems like an overly aggressive post to me.

Bah, I messed up the quote. Yes, you did say that it was aggressive, Ms. Rochelle.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

[quote="Rochelle R."]

Butler P. wrote:
Rochelle R. wrote:N33T, Kaito turned mafia.
I understand I'm not off the hook. In my defense, I was actually pressured into taking off the lynch from Kaito, and it would have been easy to preserve Kaito had I wanted to.

Yes, it would have been easy to preserve Kaito had you wanted to. You merely had to unlynch him. How does this defend you, exactly?

Also, Toran D. was only subbed out once. See game 8, page 31.

See, here it seems to me that you didn't take into account the first sentence. Idk, I thought this was clear. It seems like an overly aggressive post to me.

Your exact words, Ms. Rochelle.

Also, do you know how this entire conversation started? When you said "we could lynch Butler, he seems to have some slightly scummy traits," and I asked you to elaborate on that. All of the things that you brought up weren't scummy, and you are admitting that. So...what was the point of what we just went through? Were those the slightly scummy traits? Because I feel like we've went in a complete circle and ended up right back where we started.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Alright, let's not flip the panic switch yet, shall we? We still have approximately 57 hours left until the deadline. It's not as if we must come to a decision right now. However, it would probably be best to start moving in that direction in the last two days. If anyone expects not to be online at the deadline, because of timezones or otherwise, they must plan accordingly and get their lynch out. Every vote counts.

Mr. Fergus suddenly switching attention to Mr. Makino was...interesting. I was rather surprised that something like not addressing that a townie just died was seen as something that made him the scummiest person in the town in Fergus's eyes. It could have been an attempt to divert attention onto Makino, but obviously that isn't certain.

Also, anyone notice that Trinity has been rather inactive/lurky the past two days? We cannot let her fade into the back of our minds.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Didn't you just say that those were scummy traits about 3 pages ago?

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Rochelle R. wrote:So, in responesed to butler's first post.
1. So are new strategiis bad? It can be good without being used often.
2. I thought it defended me well.
3. Ok, you townread trinity.
4. Think it's odd that you took bwing so lightly.
5. There were a lot of mixed reads in my readlist.

Remember, these tghings aren't scummy. Just a little odd.

"Or we could lynch Butler, who seems to have slightly scummy traits.

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Makino C. wrote:
Butler P. wrote:Mr. Sukisoh - Has told us many times today and yesterday that he believes I am scummy, yet still hasn't explained how. I'm finding it hard to get a read on him...he made a decent argument when we were on to him, but his most recent read list looked rushed and hastily put together. Neutral

Ms. Trinity - I could copy past my entry from my last read list, and it would be essentially the same. Hasn't posted much, but still plenty of quality posts. Hasn't really taken a stand on anything besides all of Gizelle's madness, but perhaps her readlist will reveal more. Town read.

Mr. Fergus - Haven't been able to get a good read on him...he seems somewhat town like, but again, I can't really tell. It didn't make sense to me how he said so surely that Ms. Rochelle was not mafia. Maybe no one has defended her, but if someone did it would be too obvious that they were a scum team. Neutral/no read

Mr. Makino - People have been against him for most of the game, and I feel as though he has done a decent job of defending himself. His posts make some sense, but there is no denying that he has jumped on bandwagons a couple of times. 55/45 town to scum

Ms. Rochelle - Her most recent "readlist" was just a culmination of different thoughts that didn't combine into anything. She pointed out several things, but she can't decide if they are scummy or not apparently. She brings up so many different things, but she doesn't back them up. 45/55 scum to town

I'll admit I may have.But what I did wasn't exactly a bandwagon lynch imo. Mostly because I reasoned them. And I don't understand why you are targeting me with lynchs when clearly there are many others who mis lynched including you.

This is the post you were referring to, yes Mr. Makino? I believe the first one you didn't explain it well at the time of the lynch, however you were able to reason it the next day. Like I mentioned before, town-like attributes and scum-like attributes that melded together in a way to form a mostly neutral read. I didn't quote understand the last sentence. I thought we were talking about bandwagoning, not misslynching?

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

A few other things that I had meant to include but left out:

-At the top of your post, you said that my logic was "off." So why then did half of the posts (first two, to be specific) you commented on have nothing to do with my logic?

-Alright, referring to the second post you commented on. How was that post overly aggressive? I saw something and I was curious about it, so I asked what you meant by it. Why is asking for clarification being aggressive? The whole idea of scum hunting when you have no power roles is to get as much info as you can and use it to make an educated guess. If anything, NOT asking questions and pressing for info is scummy.

I apologize if that came off fairly ranty, but I feel strongly about the subject of accusing people of being, "too aggressive."

Game 11: Vengeful Mafia Mafia

Rochelle R. wrote:
Butler P. wrote:So, that was not the most favorable result yesterday. Now, heading into day 2, Mr. Makino and Ms. Gizelle will be under close inspection, I'm sure. I would like to see more of them, Gizelle in particular.

One of the more intriguing players from yesterday I've noticed was Mr. Andreas. He has been here throughout the entire game, but he hasn't done much. He only enlightened us on a few opinions, and didn't place a vote. This was just something I picked up from yesterday, I would be happy if I could hear opinions on it.

I know I keep coming back to this post, but it's a perfect example of Butler seeming just a little off. Not scummy, just a little unexpected. "Mr. Makino and Ms. Gizelle will be under close inspection, I'm sure." Why are you sure? It's just a little odd.

Like I said before, it was how I felt the town was going. I wasn't telling the town, "let's suspect Mr. Makino and Ms. Gizelle this day," and even if I was, why would they follow me?