Search found 19 matches for Mirror Serena

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Steveland W. wrote:Alright I have read through a bit and have seen people (Or just Nathaniel maybe) requesting peoples reads, and its also at a certain point in the game where I believe it is most appropriate to start giving reads since there is a lot of information at our disposal at this point

(But before I start that there is something that I wish to address) Yes i do realize i dont have many posts (This is my first forum game and I still have a lot to learn) However that is no excuse or reasoning for me to not try and post informatively as much as i can (I do realize that it is a terrible mistake of mine and i will try to correct it for the future (Although I shouldnt have made it in the first place))

So To the reads portion of this post I'll try and give reads for as many people as I can within the game but there might be some on which I dont have a particular read to

So I'll start off with my reads at this point

Mirror Serena, I am somewhat suspicious of her for a few reasons, now the first has been said many times before so it's perhaps not worth mentioning but to clarify it is about her Day 1 Post which said she had nothing to contribute to our discussion, In another post I did ask her to explain why she had nothing to contribute to the discussion and this is part of my next reasoning for why I am slightly suspicious of her, When she did come back to the thread and finally answered some people I felt as though she completely ignored the question that I had asked and tried to avoid it completely as she never tried to address it herself instead she gave the general inactivity speech that others have also given already the next part of my suspicions about her is that even though she said that she's back there's still not much content of worth (In my eyes at least) within her posts, yesterday while Brianna was being lynched I also felt that She just jumped on without any reasoning of her own the only 'reason' she really gave was because she agreed with what Guy F had said, and without any reasoning of her own for lynching them, I also feel as though she was a too wanting to get Plurarity off of herself when she was being lynched, and the deadline approaching. Also I feel as though her attempt or promise to contribute more hasnt been met since most of her posts dont have much in them when you compare them to for example Wilma, who also said that they would try and contribute more (I'll say more on Wilma a bit more down)


I'll discuss Mrs. Grimm next, As of right now I dont truly believe that I would be able to give her a proper read due there not being much content to pull from atm but from what I can pull from (Or the lack of what I can pull from) Will lead me to give her a somewhat Neutral read on her (At this point I do want to agree with those above in saying that she definitely needs to contribute today but I also feel that a lynch shouldnt be based solely upon her lack of contribution seeing as it's very easily likely for her to not be scum, however it is a possibility that she is scum, and there would possibly be better lynches at the time)


Next off I'd like to give my current read on Nathaniel as I do feel that its more than appropriate (or overdue) for this one b/c of the variety of posts he has had so ill give this next read, As of right now im getting a townie sort of vibe off of Nathaniel seeing as he has had what I believe a decent variety of contribution, as he constantly gives reads, and constantly updates them about every day if not more often, and he is also always looking for an opportunity to contribute by reading his earlier posts i'm somewhat certain of this atm i feel as though he is a townie that wants to be able to lynch a scum today, also another point that I do want to add is that whenever someone mentions him in a post, or asks him a question or something of the sort he actually answers their questions and also gives his thoughts where they are due and he defends himself when necessary without giving the vibe of feeling desperate to defend oneself

Next I'll say what I think on Aya at this point on time as of this point, (Similarily to me she hasnt made many posts (7) but im not going to criticize her on that) I dont know if I have more of a suspicious feeling of her or more of a neutral feeling towards her, since as of right now I dont see much content to pull from in what she has posted thus far but i do feel as though about 1/2 (maybe a little more) have been more fillery than informational, however I still cant see much content to pull from to give her the more neutral read, apart from me I do believe that she is a person that It would be good to see more of and some more contribution from so for now I'm slighly suspicious of her due to the lack of content, and contribution thus far (I perhaps might sound like a hypocrite as i havent posted much but I do try to at least include content within the posts)


Next off I'll give my current thoughts on Wilma, As of right now I do want to give her more of the townie feelings seeing as she did say that she would contribute more after what I feel to be a sincere explanation of her absence and then she immediately did fulfill on what she had owed in terms of content and what not with some reads of her own at that point in the game, again she also is another person that addresses people whenever they mention her / respond to her similarily with Nathaniel, and she doesn't ignore them at this point I feel as though she is another townie like Nathaniel that wants to be able to find scum

Next off I'm going to address my thoughts / comments on Molly at this point there's obviously a lot of content of yours to look at, right now I feel that the only person you want to be lynched is Nathaniel, which is alright I guess(A bit tunnelish to me)? But I also feel that shifting your attention to those that lack content within their posts is something that you should do since I believe at least there are those that we should worry about more than just him. Next you did state within your post(s) that you're lynching him for reasons said above yet some of these reasons aren't super credible (maybe that's the word?) since in one post you did mention that he was mostly filler but I feel that at this point that's null and void since there is a lot of contribution from him, Next off I do have a question for you (ATM I feel as though you didn't explain this much / didnt really touch upon it, but why did you believe that a Wilma + Nathaniel was most likely at that point, next off whenever you could give an indepth analysis into people that would also be greatly appreciated (You have given some indepth analysis but more would be good too) Atm a bit neutral on you from what I stated above i'm not immediately saying suspicious but i'm not leaning towards town either so i'm about in the middle maybe a bit more towards suspicious

Next I'd like to address Lulu,  honestly I don't what to think of you yet but I do want to be able to address everyone within this post so I'll ask you a few questions what are your current thoughts on our situation currently? Next I feel as though most of your "longer" posts have been more centered towards defending yourself even though it is reasonable to defend yourself, I feel as though you havent contributed in terms of trying to find scum / giving current reads, and I'd like to ask why is that? For now thats really all I have about you and ill continue on to the last person I want to address

So lastly Guy F (I've addressed everyone else I think? If I missed someone i'd like to be told so i would be able to address that person with my current thoughts) Right now youre also another person that I dont have a side on which I am leaning more towards than the other if anything maybe more towards town tbh since youre another person that has given their reads, and contributes to a point in which you address those that also address you within their posts, I also feel as though the lynch you started on Brianna was justifiable from what she said which you had already discussed within your own post but perhaps I'll ask u a question to end this what are your current thoughts on a Serena Lynch, and thoughts on those you havent had the oppurtunity to address within your posts as of now


As of right now I am going to be placing a lynch on Serena as she is the person that most of my suspicions are on, and I'd like to see some sort of explantion from her as to why she ignored the question that I had asked her so for reasons stated above Lynch Mirror Serena

Game 28: Guess Who?

Mirror Serena wrote:

Molly Q. wrote:I apologize, I missed the post that said you would be leaving for a few days but I still feel as though your activity was decreased from before. I have three scumreads (wilma serena and you, maybe add aya later if continues with bad posts)  because I am leaning toward scum on all of them. Clearly not all of them are scum but it's just showing the people who are most likely scum. I understand why this is confusing. I think you and wilma could be partners because neither of you pressure each other and are kinda just passively fine with whatever the other person does, which I find extremely scummy. I have explained my town reads but here:

Guy and Lulu have been making extremely informed posts with very good arguments against their scumreads in a very readable manner. For highlight posts check out Lulu's post condemning Wilma somewhere in the last day, you'll notice how well-thought out her argument is.

Steveland, Grimm, and Aya are all neutrals. Steveland and Grimm MUST increase their activity today but Aya was town but then her posts became progressively less informed and more just I'm spewing out bullshit to make it seem like I'm contributing. They are all probably town but aren't active enough / I'm not confident enough to say for sure.

Let's talk, people, we need to lynch scum today.

My problem with this post is what you said about Aya. While she hasnt posted much (yes i know i havent either) all her posts are slowly getting better and better. You didnt even check to see if what you said was true.

Nathaniel E. wrote:greaty we might have another completely inactive day where scum just watches town fail

i dont want to critize people for this, but honestly people need to start talking. i tried to get everyone to give their reads, but currently only a select few (molly, wilma, guy i think is it) have given them.

Mirror Serena said he/she would talk and be more active...uh yeah what happened to that idea fam

Steveland has a grand total of good old 6, albeit informative but still 6  

Mrs. Grimm literally has disappeared off the face of the Earth

Concrete SRs: none
Leaning toward scum/suspicious: Mirror Serena (pls), Mrs. Grimm (disappeared), Aya Y. (sorta filler)
Neutral: Steveland W. (meh), Wilma F. (you leave stuff half not explained but its still decent material), Lulu L. (not sure)
Leaning toward town: Molly Q., Guy F. (informative posts. molly q. could be possible scum team with lulu but seems like molly is just town who is critizing for a "tunnel attempt".)
TRs: none concrete

hopefully next time i come on i see 3 people aside from me molly and guy talk

i said i would try that doesnt mean i would become the most active person in the forum
you just said a random fact about steveland there to make your post seem longer

I know you give better reasoning later, but come on. half of these arent a reason to sr/tr people

Nathaniel E. wrote:I was at a math competition today morning so can we not fucking hate on me for literally not talking for a day (aka Molly).

Molly Q. wrote:
i disagree, although I like your analysis of the situation. I have plenty of reasons to still be lynching Nathaniel. The main assumption that you are making is that his posts are useful, and you imply that this is not debatable. Actually, this is not true. For example, just on this page, from top to bottom:

- reminded me that he was inactive because he left for a few days (but didn't note that he was inactive for a longer time than that)
- said that I was attacking him for his inactivity, I was attacking him for his SUDDEN inactivity once he WAS NOT A FOCUS OF THE MAIN CONFLICT to AVOID ATTENTION. let's read people
- quotes a post of mine and asks me clarifying questions (I guess this one is ok)
- notes that I SAID SOMETHING and that HE WILL LOOK AT IT (lol if this isn't useless I don't know what is)
- then he finally does reads after I've been pressuring him to do any content at all for the last few in game days! wow! BUT then he kinda just agrees with a lot of my reads and doesn't add much stuff new, so...

yeah so basically your entire argument was based off of this assumption that his posts were not kinda just passively fine with what's going on, which you are wrong about.

- reminded me that he was inactive because he left for a few days (but didn't note that he was inactive for a longer time than that)

explain what you mean

- said that I was attacking him for his inactivity, I was attacking him for his SUDDEN inactivity once he WAS NOT A FOCUS OF THE MAIN CONFLICT to AVOID ATTENTION. let's read people

chill out i literally wasnt here for a day and your using that as REASONING. of course others are inactive and...nope, no hate on them. starting to believe this flawed reasoning is a bit

- notes that I SAID SOMETHING and that HE WILL LOOK AT IT (lol if this isn't useless I don't know what is)

guess what? i have a LIFE. maybe you should get one

- then he finally does reads after I've been pressuring him to do any content at all for the last few in game days! wow! BUT then he kinda just agrees with a lot of my reads and doesn't add much stuff new, so...

????????????? 1. i didnt look at your reads at all. 2. i explained why i wasnt here 3. your valueing my filler over complete inactivity. maybe i should just go watch march madness all day and just forget about this game. how about that wow

btw this reaction was great ill just sum it up in case you dont wanna read: pissed at terrible reasoning

anyway also since Mirror Serena is my main SR, I'm going to ask her why she didn't answer why her posts were questionable on all levels.

ok just read up again and wait...did she just ignore the second part of my post...literally just attacked me on the fact my reasoning wasn't enough to tr/sr people, but literally just ignores everything i threw at her. Explanation?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Molly Q. wrote:if I'm supposed to respond to your reads post then I like how you explained your lynches but I don't see a lot of YOUR content in it. I see just a lot of agreeing with other people and neutral reads, which is a little scummy to me. If it's this post...

If it's your most recent post... I think it's that in hindsight... first of all I never hated you for not talking for a day. you were inactive for a large chunk of day 2 and I missed the post where you said you weren't going to be active. please. You were also inactive for longer than that and that was kinda fishy (that explains my first point which I guess you didn't understand??). The rest of your post is just you being SALTY AS FUCK because you are being scumread LOL it's funny because you don't understand how busy I am rn

finally I'd like to note that a mirror serena lynch is fine at this point, as her most recent posts also have little to no content, despite her saying "I finally have time to be active" now.

Additionally I think we should check in on Mrs. Grimm, aj isn't subbing her so she's clearly doing something...

Game 28: Guess Who?

Guy F. wrote:

Aya Y. wrote:

Wilma F. wrote:s
Also for whatever reason Guy F. is randomly putting letters in bold? I'm just confused with this guy

Lulu L. wrote:Also this is more off-topic but what is up with everyone saying I am town lol

like we have Nathaniel and Steveland "I'm confirmed to myself" then Wilma came in with "I'm personally convinced that I am town" like

Pretty sure Guy F. is spelling out I AM TOWN in bold in his posts.

Aya Y. wrote:

Nathaniel E. wrote:

Aya Y. wrote:

Pretty sure Guy F. is spelling out I AM TOWN in bold in his posts.

btw exactly in what post is he spelling that out (for some reason i can't see bold too clearly on my computer)

He just bolds a single letter in each post.  Reading them in order so far spells out I AM TO.

These were the only posts she did on day 2, i am p sure molly was referring to the fact throughout the whole of day 2 she just wrote these things which are not good points at all. Obviously not every post has to be "perfect" but to not post anything useful throughout the whole of day 2? Therefore i'm p sure molly's point still stands and your argument is null and void.

What annoys me more however is that mrs grimm and lulu were online yesterday! Mrs grimm especially, who I know must have a lot to say due to disappearing at the start of day 2 (?). Lulu, as I said before, is only active when someone is accusing her of mafia. Yes she defends herself well but it only means that she's a good player with a good sense of logic (i am literally repeating one of my older posts so see that one). I want to make them both talk but i can only lynch one of them so...

Lynch Mrs Grimm

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Molly Q. wrote:I apologize, I missed the post that said you would be leaving for a few days but I still feel as though your activity was decreased from before. I have three scumreads (wilma serena and you, maybe add aya later if continues with bad posts)  because I am leaning toward scum on all of them. Clearly not all of them are scum but it's just showing the people who are most likely scum. I understand why this is confusing. I think you and wilma could be partners because neither of you pressure each other and are kinda just passively fine with whatever the other person does, which I find extremely scummy. I have explained my town reads but here:

Guy and Lulu have been making extremely informed posts with very good arguments against their scumreads in a very readable manner. For highlight posts check out Lulu's post condemning Wilma somewhere in the last day, you'll notice how well-thought out her argument is.

Steveland, Grimm, and Aya are all neutrals. Steveland and Grimm MUST increase their activity today but Aya was town but then her posts became progressively less informed and more just I'm spewing out bullshit to make it seem like I'm contributing. They are all probably town but aren't active enough / I'm not confident enough to say for sure.

Let's talk, people, we need to lynch scum today.

Nathaniel E. wrote:greaty we might have another completely inactive day where scum just watches town fail

i dont want to critize people for this, but honestly people need to start talking. i tried to get everyone to give their reads, but currently only a select few (molly, wilma, guy i think is it) have given them.

Mirror Serena said he/she would talk and be more active...uh yeah what happened to that idea fam

Steveland has a grand total of good old 6, albeit informative but still 6  

Mrs. Grimm literally has disappeared off the face of the Earth

Concrete SRs: none
Leaning toward scum/suspicious: Mirror Serena (pls), Mrs. Grimm (disappeared), Aya Y. (sorta filler)
Neutral: Steveland W. (meh), Wilma F. (you leave stuff half not explained but its still decent material), Lulu L. (not sure)
Leaning toward town: Molly Q., Guy F. (informative posts. molly q. could be possible scum team with lulu but seems like molly is just town who is critizing for a "tunnel attempt".)
TRs: none concrete

hopefully next time i come on i see 3 people aside from me molly and guy talk

Game 28: Guess Who?

Guy F. wrote:

Mrs. Grimm wrote:Lynch Lulu Lu Molly Q is right, no shitposting this time, let's just go right into the game

Mrs. Grimm wrote:well in everyone'should defense who has talked this far not much is going on besides RVS, but no one has really given a reaction worth mentioning Molly Q.

While I was looking through the posts, i noticed these 2 posts by mrs grimm. First post agreed with molly stimulating activity while the next post gave an excuse for people not posting. It's pretty contradictory that grimm would use shitposting as an excuse for lack of activity when she just said that we need to get right into the game. Surely if there isnt a reaction then you fish for one with pressure or any other method you see fit. It's no good trying to prompt activity so early in the game and not actively finding ways to progress, and instead blame it on RVS. This is backed up in the bigger picture where we look at your whole progress in the game. Most, if not all your posts are fairly centred around something to do with activity yet I can't even remember the last time you said anything. Overall your prompting feels forced and hypocritical.

Next lets look at serena:

Mirror Serena wrote:unlynch Steveland

I wouldnt complain about having miramusosisa lynched today
i really dont have anything to say that hasnt already been said so ill go to a handstand in the corner

Mirror Serena wrote:gonna agree with Guy here. What changed your mind?
And because pressure is fun

Lynch Brianna D.

From day 1 her excuse of not contributing is that "other people said what i wanted to say". Even after the pressure from lynches, she still says that kind of stuff. There's a reason why threads still go on, it's because there is always more to say. Serena is being lazy and uncommitted which, unsurprisingly, is a scum trait. I cant deny that you made like 1 post where you questioned brianna and then 1 other post where you clarified something (probably because wilma started suspecting you as molly's partner). But we can compare it to steveland where although a lot of what he says has already been said or just scratching the surface and pointing out the obvious, you can clearly see that he actually tries. Although now that i say that, steveland doing that also makes me feel that he is trying to do the bare minimum while also trying to seem town-sided.

I also noticed that wilma never actually touched on his very first post where I pointed out his overly-aggressive jump on nathaniel despite saying that he has looked through everyone's posts several times. I know it's not much but an explanation of your thought process is still useful.

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Brianna D. wrote:Guy F, is inactivity the only reason you think mirror serena is scum?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?

Game 28: Guess Who?