Game 26: F11

Rita O. wrote:Also leona can you tell us your reason for killing OMS? lmao

Wilbur R. wrote:

Rita O. wrote:Yay we won, nice to know that my instincts are still on point xD. I had a gut feeling it was leona from start of d2 (i think i already mentioned this but wanna mention again lol) and tbh when i wanted to save wilbur at the end of day 2 i kinda wanted to lynch leona instead of ellen but i knew wilbur wouldnt agree at the time but oh well, i guess ellen wont be angry at us xD.

About the statistical analysis of post times I just used a stem and leaf graph to put down the times where wilbur came online to post "usually being the first post of a particular time frame" and then i calculated the mean and standard deviation which led me to whatever conclusion i got lol. Although its weird to say that you lied about the holiday thing because the data showed that you started going on the thread more in the mid-afternoon than evening but oh well. I am guessing you're timezone is EST tho, makes the most sense.

jesus christ
I did lie for reasons that will be disclosed later. The reason my posting time changed was because I started waking up earlier since I wanted to fix my sleep schedule (it was super messed up). I'll reveal my timezone later
You're right, I really would not have lynched Leona then as I was CERTAIN it was Ellen (content townreads fool me again)!

Rita O. wrote:Also leona can you tell us your reason for killing OMS? lmao

I think it's what she brought up; she thought he might be doctor

Leona L. wrote:

Rita O. wrote:Also leona can you tell us your reason for killing OMS? lmao

Okay I never thought OMS would be doctor, but I killed OMS because I thought you guys would clear him. I didn't kill Tierra because she just doesn't seem to make long post which OMS clearly showed he would spend time to do it. I mean if you read my posts from a scum perspective you would see how obvious it is
for example:

1) I was the first to suggest the doctor thing

2) Saying I would townread OMS and Tierra equally

3) Went over the nightkill plenty of times BECAUSE I was a little mad

and more.

Although I thought what I brought up about Morrison and Wilbur were pretty good.

ajhockeystar wrote:Scum QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/XmvkZe62icY9

Leona L. wrote:So Wilbur lied about being vacation and he lived

and I was actually on vacation and I died

Leona L. wrote:

Rita O. wrote:Also leona can you tell us your reason for killing OMS? lmao

Okay I never thought OMS would be doctor, but I killed OMS because I thought you guys would clear him. I didn't kill Tierra because she just doesn't seem to make long post which OMS clearly showed he would spend time to do it. I mean if you read my posts from a scum perspective you would see how obvious it is
for example:

1) I was the first to suggest the doctor thing

2) Saying I would townread OMS and Tierra equally

3) Went over the nightkill plenty of times BECAUSE I was a little mad

and more.

Although I thought what I brought up about Morrison and Wilbur were pretty good.

Rita O. wrote:
I didnt think it would be the doctor one coz she was like "i just realised" rather than listing it with the possibilities in her readlist. (And also it wasnt the case tee hee). But you just posted that in 2am EST....so perhaps your timezone is the california one? But then that would have meant you lied about going to sleep after the promise post lol.

The morrison one was definitly good but i had faith in him so i lynched you lol

Rita O. wrote:

ajhockeystar wrote:Scum QT: https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/XmvkZe62icY9

Also this is one of the saddest QTs lmao

Alex M. wrote:AJ always puts me with the shittiest players you guys had so much more activity and I was gonna try really hard to have an active game but holy shit we had 6 pages and the first 1.5-2 is people meming.

Wilbur R. wrote:

Rita O. wrote:About the hidden thing, it turns out AJ didnt make it a rule but i thought it was coz AJ used to keep removing the hidden status. The hidden thing per se wasnt the scummy bit, it was the fact that in your previous post you said that you will post about the actual mafia "tomorrow". This to me showed that you had to go to bed or maybe you were busy so you cant log in for the rest of the day. I checked after that day and on the members list it showed the time and date of you last being here so it wasnt hidden yet. But i checked now and i saw that it has been hidden. This means you've logged on between then and now and put your status to hidden instead of posting which begs the question, why? Thats why its scummy.

I don't think "sheeping" is a widly used term tbh because it wasnt really just me who commented about that. In day 1 both tierra and ellen got annoyed at you for BW and said that they weren't a sheep. So they probably believed it meant another word for BW. That being said, even if its day 1, i disagree that you layer the lynch straight after the first person lynched without them explaining and making themselves useful especially when it was just because he's trolling. Which is why your lynch can still, with good reason, be classed as a bandwagon to get plurality on to morrison and ensure Keanu doesnt get lynched.

About the final point, its a very weak one which is why i said that it can barely convict you of anything. But I took into consideration the reasons why the nightkill happened and i thought about doc protection, OMS being doc and the fact OMS was the first lynch on keanu. I didnt think OMS being doc made sense and I explained that in a previous post. I didnt think OMS being the least protected was the reason because there were better targets that werent likely protected either. So OMS being the first lynch on Keanu made some sense only if the mafia decided the kill on AJs post. Since you replied when RVS ended it could be said that you didnt pay attention in the RVS stage and also because OMS's post was long you could have missed the lynch bit entirely while skimming coz you disregarded it as shitpost. Again this is a very weak point against you so dont dwell on it too much.

I mostly used process of elimination to get to the decision that Wilbur is the best lynch because McGinty and Tierra are unlikely mafia. Ellen and morrison are unlikely to make the kill against OMS because they made it clear that they have acknowledged OMs's post because they replied to it. So it leaves Wilbur and Leona and Wilbur felt scummier in my eyes. Wilbur if you can convince me that you are less scummier than Leona and provide some cutting edge analysis then I will unlynch you.

Speaking of Leona, I wonder why she or ellen arent speaking. I know i said ellen probably isnt mafia but it doesnt mean she isnt scummy...

I did go to sleep after posting that i'd make a post tomorrow, then never did because i'm lazy.
aj removed my hidden status and i put it back on. Thought I said this already but I may have forgotten, it's just something we do regardless of what my role is.
The way I use sheeping is to mean that you're following a lynch for the exact same reasons that had already been put forward. It's basically the same as bandwagoning.
At the point I lynched Morrison, he was easily the best lynch for filler (Keanu didn't filler until after my post, by which time I had already stopped checking psanon I think). I think that because you think i'm scum, you're using confirmation bias in a lot of your points (by that I mean that they're very opinionated and there isnt really anything factually true in them). Your logic of not having acknowledged that a post has been made = not having read the post is flawed, and that's really the only thing you've used to eliminate Morrison and Ellen. I don't think that's valid at all. I'm not going to attempt to convince you that Leona is scum because I think she's town.
Also stop asking me to not dwell on your points while you're still lynching me. I think your case is weak, and i'm pointing out why.

Rita O. wrote:

Wilbur R. wrote:

Rita O. wrote:About the hidden thing, it turns out AJ didnt make it a rule but i thought it was coz AJ used to keep removing the hidden status. The hidden thing per se wasnt the scummy bit, it was the fact that in your previous post you said that you will post about the actual mafia "tomorrow". This to me showed that you had to go to bed or maybe you were busy so you cant log in for the rest of the day. I checked after that day and on the members list it showed the time and date of you last being here so it wasnt hidden yet. But i checked now and i saw that it has been hidden. This means you've logged on between then and now and put your status to hidden instead of posting which begs the question, why? Thats why its scummy.

I don't think "sheeping" is a widly used term tbh because it wasnt really just me who commented about that. In day 1 both tierra and ellen got annoyed at you for BW and said that they weren't a sheep. So they probably believed it meant another word for BW. That being said, even if its day 1, i disagree that you layer the lynch straight after the first person lynched without them explaining and making themselves useful especially when it was just because he's trolling. Which is why your lynch can still, with good reason, be classed as a bandwagon to get plurality on to morrison and ensure Keanu doesnt get lynched.

About the final point, its a very weak one which is why i said that it can barely convict you of anything. But I took into consideration the reasons why the nightkill happened and i thought about doc protection, OMS being doc and the fact OMS was the first lynch on keanu. I didnt think OMS being doc made sense and I explained that in a previous post. I didnt think OMS being the least protected was the reason because there were better targets that werent likely protected either. So OMS being the first lynch on Keanu made some sense only if the mafia decided the kill on AJs post. Since you replied when RVS ended it could be said that you didnt pay attention in the RVS stage and also because OMS's post was long you could have missed the lynch bit entirely while skimming coz you disregarded it as shitpost. Again this is a very weak point against you so dont dwell on it too much.

I mostly used process of elimination to get to the decision that Wilbur is the best lynch because McGinty and Tierra are unlikely mafia. Ellen and morrison are unlikely to make the kill against OMS because they made it clear that they have acknowledged OMs's post because they replied to it. So it leaves Wilbur and Leona and Wilbur felt scummier in my eyes. Wilbur if you can convince me that you are less scummier than Leona and provide some cutting edge analysis then I will unlynch you.

Speaking of Leona, I wonder why she or ellen arent speaking. I know i said ellen probably isnt mafia but it doesnt mean she isnt scummy...

I did go to sleep after posting that i'd make a post tomorrow, then never did because i'm lazy.
aj removed my hidden status and i put it back on. Thought I said this already but I may have forgotten, it's just something we do regardless of what my role is.
The way I use sheeping is to mean that you're following a lynch for the exact same reasons that had already been put forward. It's basically the same as bandwagoning.
At the point I lynched Morrison, he was easily the best lynch for filler (Keanu didn't filler until after my post, by which time I had already stopped checking psanon I think). I think that because you think i'm scum, you're using confirmation bias in a lot of your points (by that I mean that they're very opinionated and there isnt really anything factually true in them). Your logic of not having acknowledged that a post has been made = not having read the post is flawed, and that's really the only thing you've used to eliminate Morrison and Ellen. I don't think that's valid at all. I'm not going to attempt to convince you that Leona is scum because I think she's town.
Also stop asking me to not dwell on your points while you're still lynching me. I think your case is weak, and i'm pointing out why.

@Wilbur

Ellen D. wrote:Rita why did you continue to defend me on d3?
I was confused reading it

Ellen D. wrote:god damn it Tierra

McGinty P. wrote:yay we won and I played really well!!

Tierra A. wrote:I literally had no idea that the Game had gone past Day 2 at the point where I re-activated myself for a little bit.

Also I played trash on purpose, just because I knew I was semi-clear.

Rita O. wrote:This set of games is one of the rare few where the post game is less active than the game itself

McGinty P. wrote:yay we won and I played really well!!

Tierra A. wrote:Old Man Swamp MVP t b h