Game 9: Fire and Ice Mafia

Also, Robert, the main reason i suggested lynching inactives was so that we could get rid of unhelpful town and/or mafia. While a doctor may certainly be lurking, its also highly probably that a mafia is present in the lurkers as well. Also, lurking and not contributing is scummy behavior and generally something that does not help town in the slightest. As you can see, the mass number of inactives in this game makes it so that we can't even lynch anyone at this point.

Robert O. wrote:wait y was romeo subbed out he's been active?

Oh oops I worded that oddly. Lemme rephrase that...

@Romeo- Gulzar and Akina have already been subbed out.

oh nvm i read aj's post wrong ok

Good morning, Julie! What do you think of what has gone on thus far in the game? Do you think anyone may look scummier/less scummy based on the nightkills?

ajhockeystar wrote:

Robert O. wrote:wait y was romeo subbed out he's been active?

Oh oops I worded that oddly. Lemme rephrase that...

@Romeo- Gulzar and Akina have already been subbed out.

Ah.
Well, if they don't post in a couple days I would be open to their lynch then. (I would give them a couple days to arrive, catch up, and formulate opinions)

Robert, any reads on who may be town and/or scum, or not yet?

(In the case you guys want my reads as of now, they're pretty hard to form but what i'm thinking right now is:

Tori: leaning town
Everyone else who has contributed + the two who have gotten subs: null (which means not sure if town or mafia)
All lurkers: leaning scum

At this point in the game, since there have only been 4 actives (Antony [dead], Victor[dead], Tori, and i), its kind of hard to get any reads...

At this point, my vote probably will not matter anyways, so I hope I can create discussion and perhaps draw out more people with this.
Vote: Bucky

Has Bucky done anything? ima check to see if he's even talked

Nope. At this point, the only alive people who have done a substantial amount are Tori and I (although you, Robert, are probably going to contribute a lot as well).

i'll try my best, like i said im a bad scum hunter

That's perfectly fine, as long as you do something, its better than nothing at all...
*cough*LURKERS*cough*

Romeo M. wrote:Good morning, Julie! What do you think of what has gone on thus far in the game? Do you think anyone may look scummier/less scummy based on the nightkills?

Sorry about my inactive-ness earlier, I will try to contribute more today.

I'm finding it hard to tell who is acting scummy, so many inactives/lurkers >.<

Reading through the posts s'more.

Agh. Sorry, I have not talked in this forum for a bit. But I assure you, I'm a villy o_o

Namiko R. wrote:Vote: Trixie

Namiko why?

I believe it was her reasoning from last time. We had been lynching lurkers, and Namiko lynched Trixie, who had been online but not posting (aka lurking).

Julie C. wrote:

Romeo M. wrote:Good morning, Julie! What do you think of what has gone on thus far in the game? Do you think anyone may look scummier/less scummy based on the nightkills?

Sorry about my inactive-ness earlier, I will try to contribute more today.

I'm finding it hard to tell who is acting scummy, so many inactives/lurkers >.<

Reading through the posts s'more.

That would be awesome. Feel free to take your time reading, but please do say your reads/opinions on anything you have after you are done.

Bucky A. wrote:Agh. Sorry, I have not talked in this forum for a bit. But I assure you, I'm a villy o_o

You could be villy, but my 1 vote won't get you lynched, seeing as this is majority. If I see a reason to take it off/if there is a better lynch target, I am willing to change my vote. Do you have any opinions on what has happened thus far?

Bucky A. wrote:Agh. Sorry, I have not talked in this forum for a bit. But I assure you, I'm a villy o_o

Lynch Bucky

Sorry, but claiming on the spot like that in a gamemode where literally everyone will claim villy is scummy to me.

Alright, so looking through posts I'm thinking...

Trixie seems pretty suspicious. Popping in, accusing someone, and not posting since.

Namiko not really saying much until she got a lynch on her also seemed pretty weird to me.

Bucky was kind of like me with the "Sorry I haven't been on" thing. I'm not really sure what to think about him assuring us that he's Villy. He could be telling the truth, but he could also be Mafia trying to sound like a desperate townie.

Julie C. wrote:Alright, so looking through posts I'm thinking...

Trixie seems pretty suspicious. Popping in, accusing someone, and not posting since.

Namiko not really saying much until she got a lynch on her also seemed pretty weird to me.

Bucky was kind of like me with the "Sorry I haven't been on" thing. I'm not really sure what to think about him assuring us that he's Villy. He could be telling the truth, but he could also be Mafia trying to sound like a desperate townie.

I agree with what you said. As of right now, i'm not exactly sure as to what Bucky was trying to do by claiming villy, although its somewhat interesting that he said that after I voted him...
Out of the three you named, who do you think is the scummiest? I'd recommend placing a vote on one of them if you believe they have a high chance of being scum.

I have mixed feelings everywhere ;-;

As for Trixie,

"Because she is probably a mafia trying to set up on someone else."

It IS a little far fetched, but at that time Tori did look scummy, so it could be possible that Trixie is actually giving genuine feelings. However, she has not reinforced the statement nor "deny" it nor even post, but no prod was given. This shows either forum lurking or that she forgot about the game and still comes on the server regularly.

Either way, its does not seem that she will help any further.
--
As for Bucky,
claiming villy especially when you ARE one is stupid as it leaves the power roles (and other mafia, in this theme) easier to hit, so especially in a near vanilla game like this, there is no reason to claim. This opens up to policy lynch.

His post WAS within 24 hours ago (as of this post), so his lynch doesn't require immediate lynch. Heck, he trying to "retaliate" (explain) is good!
--
As for Gulzar and Akina,

They were recently subbed and its almost 24 hours, which means we already gave them AMPLE time to at least post a "Hello" post.
--
As for Julie,

Thus far, she seems to be doing of a good job of keeping up. One thing though, was her comment of too many lurkers. *cough*]
--
Did I say mixed feelings? Well, now that I thought through it , it doesn't seem to be nearly that mixed anymore n_n
For now, I'll support the lynch of Trixie.
Lynch Trixie

Votecount 2.1
*************************************
Trixie T.(3)- Namiko R., Julie C., Callister W.
Bucky A.(2)- Romeo M., Tori P.
Gulzar L.(0)-
Robert O.(0)-
Callister W.(0)-
Tori P.(0)-
Romeo M.(0)-
Akina E.(0)-
Kazuki N.(0)-
Julie C.(0)-
Not Voting(6)- Robert O., Gulzar L., Akina E., Kazuki N., Trixie T., Romeo M.
*************************************
There are 11 players alive so it takes 6 to hammer.
Deadline is Monday the 11th at 9pm EST.

Callister, any specific reasons you ignored Kazuki, Robert, Tori and I on that list? Have you townread the four of us at the moment?
If so, why have you townread Kazuki when he hasn't posted since the start of the game?